That Comedy Show review: ‘fell a little flat’

By Simon Fearn
‘That Comedy Show’ was a great idea from Adam Murphy, a collaboration between various Durham comedy troupes and stand-up comedians. Unfortunately for everyone involved, the laughs were scarce and awkward silences abundant. Nevertheless, the show was a mixed bag, and did feature some enjoyable sketches from Just Deserts and improvised comedy troupe Shellshock!.
By far the weakest aspect of the evening’s entertainment were the stand-ups. First up was Stefan Arridge, given the unenviable task of warming up the audience. His opening gag had an uncomfortably ableist flavour, and his painful impression of a white supremacist was also greeted with a stony silence. Has last joke, a clever and filthy pun, was genuinely funny, but was still hampered by a slightly mumbling delivery.
Chris Beirne was to follow. Although his delivery was just as low key as Arridge’s, the anecdotal and personal quality of his jokes did more to get the audience on side. It’s true that his gags lacked bite, but his winning personality still made for an enjoyable set.
Asa Cooper Strickland was the final stand-up, and unfortunately the most self-conscious. His material was mostly good, but his punchlines were lost in a slightly rambling delivery. His habit of bemoaning the audience’s limited reaction to his favourite jokes was endearing, but this only highlighted the flaws of a set which included a quip about people thinking transgender was a door owned by Tran for Jen to go through.
The entry of Just Deserts led to a marked improvement in proceedings, and Beirne seemed much more comfortable in his sketch roles than during his stand-up. The troupe delivered one truly brilliant sketch: a sheepish God owning up to a cuckolded Joseph. ‘Well, you know,’ squirmed Beirne’s God , ‘the Holy Spirit came over her.’
Unfortunately, the rest of their sketches did not match this bawdy high point. In general, the scenes were too long, and even the dialogue between Joseph and God contained a few lines that missed the mark completely. The routines were all two-handers, and often descended into unconvincing, high-pitched arguments, with the dialogue becoming more and more ludicrous. What’s more, the three comedians did not take on a great variety of roles. Chris Beirne seemed rooted in mild-mannered bemusement, whilst Freddie Ridell always seemed to counter this with exasperation.
Shellshock!, the ostensible headliners, finally managed to turn things around with their brand of high energy improvised comedy. The audience’s suggestions proved to be more humorous than much of the stand-up, and gave us such wonders as Zorro forced to defend his vow of chastity against Vladimir Putin in a gym changing room.
Some of the jokes did fall flat, but most were impressively sharp for an improvised routine. The group were all excellent performers, although they occasionally slipped out of character when on the side-lines. The troupe’s take on an Australian-American Shakespearean Cake Shop was spot on, and I think we can all admit that this is a difficult sketch to pull off!
I’ve seen Shellshock! a couple of times before, and they weren’t quite on top form this evening, but they were still easily the most enjoyable aspect of the comedy line-up. It is admirable of Murphy to gather so many different branches of comedy together for the evening, but unfortunately it fell a little flat. This shouldn’t put off Durham’s aspiring comedians though. Just because this particular outing didn’t go quite as planned, it doesn’t mean that a similar event in the future won’t be more successful.
Image: Steven Tatlow
