Team DU trials: born to play, or given the chance?
By Avesta Afshari-Mehr
At the start of every Michaelmas term, Team Durham’s sports clubs hold their trials, with aspiring athletes competing for a coveted place in one of the university’s official teams. For some, it is the culmination of years of training; for others, it is the beginning of a sporting journey. But when the squads are selected, a question remains: are Team Durham club trials designed to discover potential, or simply to identify those who are already good enough?
Durham, of course, has an enviable sporting reputation, regularly competing among the strongest universities in British Universities and Colleges Sport (BUCS). That success is no accident. High-performance teams need demanding selection processes, committed coaches and athletes capable of performing under pressure. Places are limited, and a university cannot promise everyone a position in its first team.
At trials for one of my strongest sports, I was disappointed to find that preference appeared to be given to those who had trained for years. Some candidates had been training practically since birth (with one fellow competitor starting training from 4 years old), arriving with technical skills, match experience and confidence that a newcomer could hardly hope to replicate in a single session. For those without that head start, the process felt less like an opportunity to demonstrate potential and more like an assessment of how much potential they had already managed to turn into results.
Durham, of course, has an enviable sporting reputation, regularly competing among the strongest universities in British Universities and Colleges Sport (BUCS). That success is no accident
Nevertheless, experience matters. Coaches cannot ignore demonstrated ability simply because another candidate has enthusiasm. But trials are surely also an opportunity to assess adaptability, determination, coachability and the capacity to improve. An athlete who has reached a high level after years of training may be the strongest choice for immediate competition; an athlete who has progressed rapidly in a short time may have considerable potential for the future. If selection considers only the performance visible on trial day, it risks overlooking the very qualities that make development worthwhile.
And the atmosphere can compound that problem. In highly competitive trials, fellow candidates quickly learn that they are not simply teammates learning together… but rather that they are rivals competing for a limited number of places. There is little incentive to encourage someone else when their success could mean your own rejection. Instead of community morale, the process can create an environment of anxiety, comparison, and perhaps even a degree of resentment.
There is a distinction between communicating that someone has not met a selection standard and making their departure a public spectacle. Coaches can be honest without turning failure into entertainment.
One experience I found particularly striking was at trials for a different DU sport, where candidates who had not met the required standard were loudly identified and told to leave partway through a game. The practice was undeniably effective at making the selection process clear, but it was also so humiliating. An acquaintance I met during the trials, who was second to be picked out, complained about how degraded he felt, his morale crushed as the rest of us in the sports hall just seemed to stare at him as he walked out.
But there was something motivating about the experience, too. Being confronted with how much further I had to go made me want to improve. But motivation born of embarrassment is not necessarily sustainable, and not everyone will respond in the same way.
Neither reaction should be dismissed. Competitive sport inevitably involves disappointment; athletes must learn to handle rejection. But there is a distinction between communicating that someone has not met a selection standard and making their departure a public spectacle. Coaches can be honest without turning failure into entertainment.
Perhaps the most encouraging development is the growing number of sports societies offering development squads (‘Dev Squads’). In my first year at Durham, these seemed to be available in only a handful of sports, with my top sport refusing to consider it. Their expansion since then suggests that more societies are recognising the value of creating pathways beyond their most competitive teams.
And Dev Squads offer something important: a place to learn the sport, develop technique, and gain experience without the immediate pressure of competing at the highest level. They also help clubs retain enthusiastic beginners who might otherwise walk away after a discouraging trial. Given time and proper coaching, some may progress into competitive squads.
Not everyone who attends trials will make the team. That is an unavoidable reality of competitive sport. What should be avoidable is leaving people with the impression that, unless they arrived with years of experience already behind them, they never had a meaningful chance.
The best trials should identify who can compete today while recognising who might become an exceptional athlete tomorrow. After all, nobody becomes a seasoned player without first being a beginner. And if Durham wants its sporting success to endure, it should make sure there is room for the next generation to begin.
Image: Adeline Zhao

