Take the lead from students to avoid inequalities in exams

By Joseph Monaghan

In the midst of the Coronavirus chaos, universities across the country have been faced with an unprecedented situation. The timing of the crisis in the UK has been such that it will be impossible to hold exams on campus – a fact that Durham realised early on, announcing that they would seek to move exams online. This effectively meant turning them into 48 hour take-home exams of the kind already used by some departments. However, the University has failed to consider the full implications of this for students and should reconsider their approach.

Although the University regularly sends out email updates, the concerns of many students around this new exam style are still not being addressed. Details of how they will be run are still thin on the ground for a lot of us, especially in subjects where the style preferred by the university clashes with that preferred by the department. As a physics student, at the time of writing, my department hasn’t communicated to us how long exams will be available for, how students will submit their answers, or how much they will count for. This raises questions about how fair this change is between subjects, with some students facing a radical change to what they’ve been preparing for and some able to continue as normal.

The University has failed to consider the full implications of this for students

There’s also a big issue around the timetable. With exams expanded to take up 48 hours, it is inevitable that if exams are started when they were originally scheduled to start, there will be clashes. Departmental responses to this have been between silence on the issue or telling students that if clashes happen, there’s nothing they can do and students will have to complete both exams at the same time, as has been told to psychology students. This is a huge problem for students taking modules from multiple departments. Not only is the prospect of having to do this unfair, but with the absence of communication in this area or any signs of collaboration between departments to resolve this, students are left in the dark as to what they have to prepare for, a far cry from the fair exam system we are used to.

The biggest issue by far, however, is that some students will not be able to perform as well under these conditions regardless of what the university does to ensure exams are fair at their end. The university’s assumption that all students are able to study away from Durham is a false one. There are students without a stable home life or space in which to concentrate, those without the access to a stable internet connection, those whose mental health suffers in isolation, those without a desk or a laptop or a quiet place to work, those who are now caring for relatives, all of whom may be stuck in one place with no way to resolve these issues. All of which prevent students from achieving anything close to what they’re capable of. These are issues that the university will not be able to find a quick fix for, that an SAC form can’t accurately compensate for, and expecting these students to be judged as if these issues aren’t affecting their performance, would be a huge error on the University’s part.

A far cry from the fair exam system we are used to.

So what’s to be done? Students have been quick to propose a wide range of solutions. Some are calling for exams to be cancelled outright, and others for exams to be cancelled for non-finalists, both of which are positions taken by other UK universities. These would have the advantage of recognising the unfair nature of taking the exams this year, but to penalise students aiming to achieve more this year than in previous years, would put a lot of pressure on either past or future results. Some support a choice between accepting a previous mark or taking the exam; a particularly intriguing version of this proposed by Durfess suggests that the online exams should go ahead but students should be awarded, at minimum, their lowest average mark from previous years to reflect how they would have performed normally, with the open letter proposing this signed by 35% of the undergraduate population. While this doesn’t work for everyone, this kind of compromise addresses more of the challenges faced by students at this time.

Regardless of what direction the University takes with exams though, one thing they can do is communicate more – updating students frequently on the specifics of what they are planning, what discussions are being had, and how they are responding to specific questions from students, will go a long way in easing the stress placed on us by the current state of uncertainty. Although no solution will be perfect, a reasonable decision is within the reach of the University.

Photograph: PublicDomainPictures via Pixabay