Sweeney Todd review: ‘a masterpiece’

By Jess Derwent

DULOG’s Michaelmas production of ‘Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street’ has been greatly anticipated by many, and I was no exception. As high as my expectations were for the production, I was blown away by their opening night production. Even now writing out the play’s title I can hear the chorus singing it.

The Assembly Rooms was an ideal location for such an epic production, with a palpable excitement emerging from the packed audience before the performance even began. A few sparse clues onstage (a small lamppost, mouldy pies) gave an impression of how the play would be performed – lavish use of staging to create a multi-dimensional and semi-cinematic experience.

The play’s opening was spectacularly dramatic and atmospheric, as the cast appeared and sang the eponymous song, that would become a kind of harrowing mantra throughout. As more and more members joined in, the song increased in intensity, starting with one of the chorus singers, Rhys Rodrigues. The use of smoke and lighting was particularly impressive, creating a kind of blinding confusion that would add to the hysteria of the play’s opening. Immediately the audience was immersed in the dramatic landscape of the play, and this was undeniably continued throughout the production.

Sweeney Todd was an incredibly fluid production, and this is reflected in many aspects. For instance, it is impossible to single anyone out from such a stellar cast, as each actor moved ceaselessly between singing and acting. Similarly, scenes ceaselessly moved into the next, and transitions were kept incredibly smooth due to the efforts of the orchestra, with music powerfully binding the play and its characters together.

True to form, there were plenty of bloody and horrific scenes, in particular the climatic double murder of Judge Turpin (Charlie Keable) and the Beggar Woman, Todd’s estranged and deranged wife (Rosie Weston). Another standout scene for its gritty horror and intensity was Judge Turpin’s self-flagellation scene. Staging here was striking, with Johanna (Florence Russell) standing on an overhead box with a mesh covering, heightening the atmosphere of emotional unrest. Another scene worth highlighting was the scene in which Anthony, as played by Arthur Lewis, goes to rescue Johanna from the mad-house. Sweeney Todd’s production team should be proud of the creativity in their staging here, as the chorus played the mentally insane inmates, and covered the stage rocking and laughing unsettlingly.

Particular credit should be given to Elliot Mather and Sophie Forster, in their portrayal of the famous duo, Sweeney Todd and Mrs Lovett. Mather and Forster were spectacularly dark and funny; despite depicting murderers who trick people into unknowingly becoming cannibals, their performances were so moving that I couldn’t help empathising with them. Although Forster’s portrayal of Mrs Lovett was a consistent source of entertainment throughout, my one criticism would be that she somewhat stole the show from Mather’s performance as the eponymous character. As the play progressed, Mather’s performance somewhat lagged in comparison to his co-star, which could be potentially due to the demanding singing required for the role. Overall, this is only a slight criticism of the show, as Sweeney Todd was unquestionably well-performed.

Yet, what made the performance so spell-binding was the balanced interplay between comedy and horror. Just as the transcendental love story of Anthony and Johanna acts as a foil to the sickening acts of Mrs Lovett and Sweeney Todd, so the moments of comedy provided much-needed light relief. At times the comedy was absurdly hyperbolic, as epitomised by the performance of Joe McWilliam, wriggling around onstage in the role of the rival Barber and fake Italian, Pirelli. Although the comedy was occasionally somewhat unrealistic, this only enhanced Sweeney Todd’s presentation of a corrupt society, so far removed from normality. If its characters appeared insane, it was clear that this was a consequence and a necessity of the world they were forced to inhabit.

Director Qasim Salam has undeniably produced a masterpiece production, which is evocative and poignant from its opening number to the last. As Tobias’s (Jasper Millard) final words echoed into the audience, it was clear that we had been witness to a truly remarkable and impressive show. Truly, Sweeney Todd is a student production not to be missed.

‘Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street’ will be shown at The Assembly Rooms Theatre from Wednesday, 16th November until Saturday, 19th November at 19:30. Book your tickets here.

Photograph: Samuel Kirkman