Supreme Federal Court of Brazil denies appeals to Bolsonaro’s 27-year sentence

By William Powell

On the 18th of November, the Supreme Federal Court of Brazil published its ruling rejecting the appeal of former president Jair Bolsonaro, upholding his 27-year prison sentence for plotting a coup. The 70-year-old was convicted in September for attempting to undermine the result of the 2022 election, after losing to now-President Lula, and conspiring to overthrow the government.

Bolsonaro’s conviction stems from a turbulent post-election period in which he repeatedly questioned the integrity of Brazil’s voting system, encouraged supporters to doubt the outcome and fuelled anger within his political base. Pro-Bolsonaro demonstrations across the country culminated on the 8th of January 2023, when thousands of his supporters attacked the National Congress and presidential palace. Many rioters had said they sought to incite a ‘military intervention’ that would overturn the election and restore Bolsonaro to office.

However, the riots were suppressed and the coup attempt collapsed, resulting in the arrests of members of Bolsonaro’s inner circle. Prosecutors later argued that Bolsonaro’s rhetoric and actions helped lay the groundwork for the attacks, including by circulating draft decrees that could have enabled military intervention and restored him to power. After months of investigation, the Court ordered his detention and placed him under house arrest as the trial began.

Bolsonaro’s conviction stems from a turbulent post-election period, in which he repeatedly questioned the integrity of Brazil’s voting system, encouraged supporters to doubt the outcome and fuelled anger within his political base

The fight over Bolsonaro’s fate quickly attracted attention from the United States. In July 2025, President Donald Trump imposed a 50% tariff on Brazilian imports, framing the move as a response to what he called a “witch-hunt” against Bolsonaro. At the same time, the U.S. Treasury installed sanctions on Alexandre de Moraes, the Supreme Court jurist overseeing Bolsonaro’s case, accusing him of violating human rights and orchestrating politicised prosecutions – naming Bolsonaro directly. The White House also revoked de Moraes’s visa, escalating tensions further. President Lula criticised these actions, stating on X that “the interference of the American government in Brazilian Justice is unacceptable.” These moves added weight to Bolsonaro’s claims and signalled a direct challenge to Brazil’s sovereignty.

At the heart of the transnational political battle is Eduardo Bolsonaro – member of the Brazilian National Congress and son of the indicted former president. Earlier this year, Eduardo moved to the U.S. and engaged extensively with the White House and conservative media, portraying his father’s trial as politically motivated. He has also publicly claimed credit for the 50% tariffs. On the 14th of November, a panel of the Supreme Federal Court voted to put Eduardo Bolsonaro on trial over obstruction, siding with the prosecutors that he “repeatedly sought to subordinate the interests of Brazil and the entire society to his own personal and family agenda.”.

This isn’t the first time he’s engaged with the U.S. for his father’s benefit: Eduardo has developed relationships with figures such as Steve Bannon and even lobbied U.S. senators in his quest to become Brazil’s ambassador to Washington in 2019. These connections made him a key conduit for external support, able to tap into political and media networks in defence of his father.

[The] Supreme Federal Court voted to put Eduardo Bolsonaro on trial over obstruction, [claiming] that he “repeatedly sought to subordinate the interests of Brazil and the entire society to his own personal and family agenda.”

While pressure from the U.S. plays out on the international stage, accusations of persecution risk exacerbating existing unrest as Bolsonaro’s supporters continue to view the legal proceedings as politically motivated. Such aggravation threatens to reignite demonstrations and undermine the legitimacy of Lula’s government: protestors have already been spotted with banners outside the federal police headquarters calling for Lula and de Moraes to be removed. Although Bolsonaro’s trial was hailed as a democratic milestone, demonstrating accountability amid a history of political corruption, these mounting pressures are now testing the durability and resilience of Brazil’s institutions.

However, some analysts argue that the current situation may backfire on Bolsonaro. With many Brazilians holding an unfavourable view of the U.S. president, the tariffs and sanctions have prompted unity across parts of the political spectrum, with lawmakers condemning perceived international interference and overreach. “No citizen, especially representatives elected by the people, can tolerate foreign aggression against Brazil, regardless of the alleged justification,” said Senator Alessandro Vieira, a frequent critic of Lula. This backlash may generate a rally-around-the-flag effect, strengthening Lula’s position and undercutting Bolsonaro’s narrative; even figures on the right criticised the U.S. intervention, suggesting that, instead of empowering Bolsonaro’s movement, attempts to stoke division from abroad may ultimately undermine it.

Image: Paladinum2 via Wikimedia Commons