Sunshine on Leith review: ‘sincere and down-to-earth’

By Johanna Farr

Sunshine on Leith warmed up and grew throughout its performance. The opening was a little rocky: some troubles with microphone dynamics led to words getting lost, and the opening number ‘Sky Takes The Soul’ didn’t feel quite secure – which was a shame, since its portrayal of weary, fearful and disillusioned soldiers in Afghanistan was one of the moments in the musical where the lyrics (such as you could hear) chimed most poignantly with the setting. There was a little feeling of awkwardness about launching into the exuberant choreography of the second song, ‘I’m On My Way’,  but this awkwardness fit with the plot as the viewer could certainly empathize with the jarring experience of returning to civilian life that protagonists Ally (Alex Grover) and Davy (Adam Richardson) must have been feeling. The lingering awkwardness throughout the production was offset by general good humour and enthusiasm, which like its protagonists proved itself determined to adjust and learn how to have a good time. On the whole, the opening was enjoyable but not remarkable, something that you were predisposed to like in spite of a few glitches.

Aesthetically the musical was similarly a good-willed mixed bag. The simple, plain black stage and lack of set contrasted oddly with the amount of props brought onto it – watching multiple cast members clean and dust the nonexistent set with a large variety of cleaning products during ‘Should Have Been Loved’, for instance, was pretty much exactly on the border between unconvincingly ridiculous and visually enjoyable. The choreography redeemed this scene, though, tipping the balance into enjoyably ridiculous, as the many rainbow coloured feather-dusters became a set of spinning dance props and Jean’s (Darcy Van Eerten) workmates became a delightful musical chorus. There were a couple of ingenious moments with the lighting that were particularly impressive: static bursts of strobe lighting to echo the rattle of guns, or the dark theater being filled with blue flashing lights combined with ambulance sound effects, worked very well to immerse the audience in the same tense atmosphere as the characters.

The programme makes several mentions of the importance of people’s relationships, and this focus really came through in the acting, which was in general much more convincing and moving in the scenes between just two people, holding up slightly less well in the scenes which included the whole family. Hannah Fisher, as Liz, had some truly compelling moments and shone through as an extremely sympathetic and believable character. The characters of the men of the musical took more warming to, but scenes between Richardson’s Davy and Grover’s Ally presented a relationship that felt authentic through simple, naturalistic acting which by the second act was impressively emotionally charged. The scene in which Davy begs Ally not to rejoin the army was one of the highlights of the musical.

In general, though the acting came through more strongly in the scenes involving fewer people, the best songs of the production were the ones which involved more of the cast. The group numbers became more and more confident and polished throughout the evening, culminating in a truly enjoyable rendition of ‘I’m Gonna Be (500 Miles)’ complete with audience participation. All of the songs were enjoyable and well-rendered. The difficulty of the production, as with many jukebox musicals, was in integrating the musical numbers convincingly into the storyline, so that many of the songs didn’t feel quite natural. But when it worked, it really worked – ‘Let’s Get Married’, for instance, was one of the more triumphant moments, because the characters bursting into song felt natural for the pub setting, and the song allowed for both great music and glimpses of the individual attitudes of all the characters, who interacted in a very genuine and human way. In terms of solo talent, Van Eerten as Jean stole the show, singing the eponymous ‘Sunshine on Leith’ to her hospitalized husband in a clear, genuine, and wrenchingly moving performance.

Overall, Sunshine on Leith is an enjoyable production in good spirits – not technically wonderful, but with some moments of genuine emotion and flashes of talent. It’s not quite worth walking five hundred miles to see perhaps, but certainly worth the walk to Trevs if you’re after a sincere, down-to-earth musical.

‘Sunshine on Leith’ will run until Sat 18th June at Trevelyan College. Book your tickets here.

Photograph: Sam Harrison