Students can save by shopping around

Robinsons' fruit and vegtables

by Joanna Thom

A Palatinate investigation has revealed the savings that can be made by students willing to look a bit further afield.

Many students located in the viaduct have often been happy to use the very local Tesco express as their main source for grocery shopping.

However some students might be alarmed to find out that there are large price differences between the two stores on same brand products. This means that just by walking the extra few meters, students are likely to make a large saving.

Palatinate calculated the saving that walking the extra distance to the Tesco in town, would add up to.

Four people, eating 500g of Tesco brand pasta, 300g of Tesco brand chicken, a jar of Trattoria pesto, two Tesco packaged onions, 200g of Tesco packaged carrots and finishing with a bar of Cadburys Dairy milk, making the extra journey would save ÂŁ1.51 altogether.

While the meal for four added up to ÂŁ7.34 at the larger Tesco in town, at the often more convenient Tesco Express, the meal was ÂŁ8.85.

This was calculated on same brand products, not factoring the extra savings that would be made when shopping around for the cheaper offers that can be available at the larger Tesco.

Many students, particularly those who live out, have noticed the difference and are not happy about it. The majority of those spoken to indicated that they do normally walk the extra distance in order to make the savings.

Tesco Metro proved to be cheaper in comparison to Tesco Express on Cadbury’s chocolate, Cathedral City cheese, Tesco pasta and Ben & Jerries cookie dough.

Isabella Petrie is one student who feels strongly about the price differences: “It makes me so angry. I don’t understand why basic products such as kidney beans or chopped tomatoes need to be so much more expensive at the smaller store.”

Heather Nickson, a 3rd year student, lamented the difference in prices: “The price difference bothers me! I don’t understand why everything cannot be the same price wherever you get it from.”

Hannah Cannell explained that the price difference did have a large effect on where she shopped: “When I lived in the viaduct I always walked past the tiny Tesco to Tesco Metro because it was cheaper even if Tesco Express had what I needed. And they mostly only sell branded stuff in Tesco Express.”

While Mollie Little summed up her attitude towards the lack of choice in the smaller Tesco: “Tiny Tesco is very limited.”

However some students were not concerned by the price differences, with many saying that they understood that the smaller store would need to have higher prices because its’ profits were lower.

Rachel Metcalf, a second year Law student, said: “However, if I do need something when I am in the house I would go to Iceland as it is cheaper for milk, bread and biscuits. I understand that they do need to charge higher prices though, they are a smaller shop so need to make more money somehow.”

The smaller Tesco Express has longer opening hours, making it more appealing to students who want a convenient late night store.

While its neighbour Iceland closes at 6:30 pm, Tesco stays open until 11 pm, indicating its attempts to appeal to students.

Prices were found to vary between broccoli outlets: Tesco Express: 325g = ÂŁ1.05; Iceland : 400g – ÂŁ1.00; Tesco Metro: 1000g = ÂŁ2.50; Robinsons: 1000g = ÂŁ2.66

These price differences do not only affect Durham, with a survey run by Confused.com in Bristol showing that they had found similar differences there.

Students who are able to make the extra journey to Tesco Extra, the larger out of town store, will find a far greater variety of products at often lower prices.

Students willing to pay the delivery costs of an online order are also able to shop around for even lower prices.

Camilla Hadland is one student who will make the car journey to the out of town Tesco for the cheaper prices: “I always drive to big Tesco and definitely don’t mind doing that as there’s so much more choice – and it is so much cheaper.”

Some students however do not think the cheaper prices are worth the longer walk. Rhiannon Ellis said: “I’m lazy and only go to the tiny Tesco unless I’m near the giant Tesco. I hardly ever go to the medium one in town.”

Other Options

While Tesco has more stores in Durham than any other grocery store chain, there are other options which tend to be neglected by students but will often offer a better value for money as well as allowing students to support the local economy.

Robinsons Greengrocers provides an alternative option for students looking to buy fruit and vegetables. Conveniently located near the viaduct, opposite the smaller Tesco Express, this is within metres of many students who live out.

Robinsons allows customers to purchase items individually, meaning students do not need to fear that they won’t be able to consume a large packet before the sell by date.

Robinsons produce is from a wholesale market in Gateshead, with as much local produce as possible. 45% of their customers are students during term time.

While the freedom over size works to the benefit of many students, most should also find the lower prices appealing.

Carrots are priced at 88p a kilo, a saving of 42p for every kilo from the larger Tesco Metro’s bagged carrots, and 2p a kilo for their loose carrots.

Additionally onions are also 88p per kg, a further saving of 2p a kg from Tesco Metro’s loose carrots.

However, while it is a great option for fruit and vegetables, Robinson’s is only a greengrocers, so for time strapped students, who want to purchase everything in one go, this may not be the ideal place.

And if students looking for fresh products don’t want to venture outside of the centre of town, the indoor market can provide a wide variety of fresh products with their fruit and vegetable prices trumping the other stores previously mentioned.

A kilo of onions at the market stall will cost 86p, saving you 4p a kilo from Tesco and 2p from Robinsons. Fresh meat, fish, cheese and bread are also available from a variety of stalls in the market.

The Tesco Brand

Customers are used to seeing the familiar Tesco brand, however, Tesco has some other ventures, which mean that it is making money beyond the neon signs.

Harris and Hole, a coffee shop business in the South East counts Tesco as one of its major shareholders.

Their investment in the chain of coffee shops means that customers who want to avoid the big brand names and support more independent businesses, might find themselves unwillingly contributing towards the Tesco brand.

Other businesses include Dobbies, a chain of Garden centres and Euphorium bakery,

The Tesco chief executive Philip Clarke wrote in a blog post for Tesco this month that Tesco has always been upfront about its backing of these smaller businesses.

When addressing the question of why it doesn’t include the Tesco brand he said: “The H+H brand is part of its value – its distinctiveness and appeal. It’s the Tolley’s business, their brand. Our investment helps them to take it further.”

Some students did not respond positively to the revelation about Tesco.

Morgan Bestwick said: “I really dislike the fact that you don’t know Tesco is running a business. I prefer going to smaller coffee shops where I know I’m contributing to the local economy but now even they might be owned by a big name.”

Big Savers

Students looking for Kellogg crunchy nut cereal will save 13p on a 500g box by buying it at Tesco Metro rather than Tesco Express. However at Iceland a 750g box is 68p cheaper than the smaller box at Tesco Metro.

If a student is looking to buy bagels, it is worth making the longer trip as not only is a packet of five New York bagels 8p cheaper at Tesco Metro than Tesco Express, but Tesco Metro also currently sells two packets for ÂŁ2, allowing a saving of ÂŁ1.36.

Iceland was the cheapest place for a one kilogram bag of long grain rice, priced at ÂŁ1 compared to Tesco Metro where it costs ÂŁ1.39 and Tesco Express where it costs ÂŁ1.46.