Students asked to vote again in NUS referendum

by Hannah Shaddock

Debate about whether Durham Student Union should be affiliated with the National Union of Students begins anew this week, as voting opens in the third referendum on the issue.

Voting opened at 10am on Monday and closes at 5pm on Friday. The referendum is the third to be held on the issue in the last two years.

The vote takes place almost exactly a year since Durham students chose to disaffiliate from the NUS in last year’s referendum, which was called after the aggressive actions of the NUS caused a debate about multiculturalism at the Durham Union Society to be cancelled.

Controversy began when two executive members of the NUS sent a letter to the Union Society which seemed to threaten violence if the debate, featuring members of the British National Party, went ahead.

The letter attracted significant criticism with its strongly-worded claims, asserting that the NUS would be “mobilising nationally and organising coach loads of students to demonstrate at your university,” and “If any students are hurt in and around this event, the responsibility will lie with you”.

The debate was subsequently cancelled after the University deemed it a safety risk to go ahead. An internet campaign, known as “Durham University Students for Freedom of Speech”, was set up in response, and attracted several thousand members.

In recognition of the high profile of the case, last year’s NUS President Wes Streeting came to Durham to personally address the issue in front of a crowd of around 300 students. Although he agreed that the NUS had made a “huge, monumental cock-up”, Streeting’s appearance did little to appease students and a petition was filed shortly afterwards which prompted the referendum.

Despite the fact that a vote had already been held on the issue in November, with 80% voting in favour of affiliation with the NUS, a second referendum took place in March. The result was close, but the majority of students voted in favour of the motion, with 1295 students voting to leave the NUS, and 1217 voting to stay.

DSU President Sam Roseveare is taking a pro-affiliation stance on this week’s referendum, speaking, along with current NUS President Aaron Porter, in favour of re-affiliation in a debate last Sunday.

Speaking with Palatinate, Roseveare explained his view, stressing the support that the NUS provides to Student Unions behind the scenes. He spoke of the “positive direction and resources” which membership to the NUS would bring, helping “big changes” to take place within the DSU.

While this year management of the DSU’s finances is improving, last year’s debate took place amidst concern at the DSU’s disorganised financial state, prompting questions on the value for money which membership to the NUS (which this year, should DSU re-affiliate, would cost ÂŁ24,841) provided. Roseveare suggested that many students voting in last year’s referendum did not realise that they had been “let down, not by the NUS, but by the DSU”.

On the political benefits of membership to the NUS, Roseveare referred to the DSU’s “responsibility to ensure [its] students are heard on a national level”, and asserted that it was hard for an organisation to “become great in isolation”.

He reiterated these points in the debate, referring to affiliation as a good thing for “the strength of the union in general”, and asserted that, with the cheap drinks prices available through the NUS, membership “pays for itself”.

NUS President Aaron Porter tackled the wider political challenges which the NUS as a whole faces, admitting that the last six months has been “tumultuous” for the organisation. He spoke of the ability of the NUS to assert the “rights and responsibilities” of students in the face of rising tuition fees, referring later to the NUS’ campaign to get MPs from all parties to sign a pledge on tuition fees as “the most effective campaigning tactic of 2010”.

Speaking in opposition were Chris Sibbald, Honorary Secretary of Glasgow University  Union, and Andrew Keenan, Student President of St Andrews University, 2008/10. Keenan asserted that the “deeper problems of NUS membership have not been resolved”, and that it remained “a troubled organisation”. He also contested that their perceived allegiance to “certain political parties compromises the NUS”.

Sibbald held up the example of Glasgow, who have never been a part of the NUS, as a way a union can represent itself effectively, asserting the limits of membership to a “bureaucracy that resides in London”. He questioned the membership fee, asking “Why should [students] have to pay to be represented?”, and described the discounts offered through the NUS as a “sham”.

Questioning focused on the lack of publicity and the scheduling of the referendum, as well as the perceived allegiance of the NUS to certain political parties, although this was thoroughly refuted by Aaron Porter. The validity of the assertion that membership to the NUS provides the cheapest alcohol prices also came under fire.

Information from both sides of the debate can be found on the DSU website. To place your vote, go to vote.dsu.org.uk. The result will be announced in Kingsgate Bar shortly after voting closes on Friday.