Students allege unfair employment practices
TWO INTERNATIONAL STUDENTS formerly employed by Shaheen’s Indian Bistro have approached Palatinate with allegations that they were treated unjustly by the owners, Mr and Mrs Khan.
Ray Dopaishi, 23, and one student, who wishes to remain anonymous, claim that they were paid beneath the National Minimum Wage, that they were never given written statements of terms of employment or payslips, and that wages promised to them were withheld unreasonably.
The full details of their concerns were set out in a letter from Ian Faircloth, of the Student Employment Service (SES) and posted to Mr and Mrs Khan, in the hope that the dispute could be settled informally.
After several weeks and no reply, the same letter was dropped through the letterbox of Shaheen’s but the complainants are yet to receive a response.
When Palatinate questioned Mrs Khan about the allegations, she claimed never to have heard of them. On being offered the opportunity to assess the allegations, Khan declined on the grounds that they were ‘petty’.
Mr Dopaishi, who worked as a waiter for Shaheen’s over a period of eight months, told Palatinate: “As an International student with no inkling of the minimum wage laws in this country, I joined Shaheen’s in the spirit of goodwill. I trusted them when they told me that my wage was fair because I believed that no restaurant with such a large clientèle of students would stoop to unscrupulous behaviour towards its student employees. I suppose this was a hard learned lesson for me.”
The anonymous Durham student worked first as a dishwasher and later as a waiter: “I took up work at Shaheen’s as I was in need of finances. Since I knew Ray was working there I asked him for a recommendation and started as a member of kitchen staff. As an international student with work experience I was aware of some minor employment regulations and therefore asked to be provided with payslips. However the Khans rejected my request and I resigned after two nights.
“In my second term of employment at Shaheen’s I worked as a waiter alongside Ray for two weeks. During this time, I was frequently yelled at and asked to do large amounts of work, sometimes with no time for a break. I was accused of stealing tips and was not allowed to have a soft drink behind the bar.”
Having for months sought documentation from the Khans, Mr Dopaishi finally received on the 20th September a rather sparse letter of recommendation for future employers, which claimed that he worked 16 hours per week at National Minimum Wage. It was this letter which finally precipitated his resignation.
“I brought to attention the false details in the letter and demanded payslips and suggested that they bring my wage up to standard or I would resign. After a week’s work, I asked for my wages. The Khans promised to pay my wages the following Sunday. Upon calling them on Sunday, they said that they would not pay me for my weeks work because I had been “stealing tips”. Needless to say, I was both shocked and annoyed.”
“The purpose of publicising this story,” continued Mr Dopaishi, “is in part to warn other students, especially international students, about employment practices by some establishments and most importantly to seek employment through the SES for their own protection. It is my sincere wish that one day all student employment could be sourced through the SES. We are willing to follow this case through to till the end. It is our intention to make certain that this will not happen to any student in the future.”
A spokesperson for the SES said, “Although the jobs weren’t found through the University’s Student Employment Service (SES), both students sought advice from the SES who acted as advocates in the hope that the dispute could be settled informally.”
