Student workers criticise Durham SU over job changes revealed on Instagram 

By Isla Mustin

Durham Students’ Union (DSU) is facing backlash after student employees learned of changes to student staff roles not through formal communication, but through an Instagram story advertising a new zero-hour position.

Student receptionist staff known as ASK Assistants, who previously held guaranteed-hours contracts with a minimum of four hours’ work per week, learned that their roles would not be available to apply for next year when the SU advertised a new “student staff” position on Instagram. This new role offers no guaranteed hours, and requires all staff who want the role to apply. 

The job description found on the SU website for the new role of ‘student staff’ states: “We are not able to provide guaranteed weekly or monthly hours of work”. 

This Instagram advert of the zero-hour position prompted student staff to inquire about why they had not been informed about the ASK Assistant role not being renewed. 

This communication failure was made worse an hour after this Instagram story as ASK Assistants were notified formally for the first time about their current roles not being renewed for next year in a WhatsApp message urging them to apply for the zero-hour role. 

Palatinate spoke to a former ASK Assistant who said: “There was no indication this was happening. It’s ridiculous we found out about this change from Instagram, not our manager. It’s so disappointing that the student union would treat such committed individuals so poorly. 

“This means those who may have wanted to apply for college bar staff now cannot do so, under the assumption they would continue working for the SU. It was not communicated well at all, and we were completely blindsided.”

Following student concerns, SU CEO Gareth Hughes sent an email acknowledging the communication failure.

“We’re sorry that the number, complexity, and overlap of ongoing conversations meant we slipped up on communicating things in the right order to the right people, so everyone knows what they need to, at the same time.

He added that new contracted roles will be available and will be designed over the summer with staff consultation. 

Hughes told Palatinate that these would include, for example, social media content creators, as in previous years.

The email continued saying, “Any job we offer students will be consistent with our commitment to being a good employer, so we’d assume these jobs would be offered on a contract which guarantees a reliable number of hours a week. These roles will be discussed, designed, and decided over the summer.

“There’s been some confusion that we were asking ASK Assistants to work zero-hour contracts. That isn’t what the current advert says. We understand why the confusion arose. We’re doing a lot, and communicating a lot at pace. We’re sorry this happened, but we’re pleased to clarify that we remain committed to being a good employer of students.”

However students remain sceptical due to the mixed messaging. Speaking to Palatinate, one former ASK Assistant said, “The email states that the advertisement is not asking students to work zero-hour contracts. Except, that’s exactly what the advertisement says. This new position is explicitly precarious.

“They say they will be looking at contracted work, but it can’t be confirmed what that work is or if existing staff will be strong candidates for the new roles.”

Students described feeling anxious and the emotional toll of being kept in the dark. Another former ASK Assistant told Palatinate: “As a working-class student who relies on this job, the uncertainty means I’ll spend the summer in dread and anxiety, unsure if I’ll be able to support myself next year.”

“There has been a complete lack of empathy from staff about how this affects people who rely on these jobs to pay rent or buy food next year.

“I’ve built relationships with my coworkers and managers. To not have been briefed or consulted before these changes were advertised to students at large feels insulting.

They added that the lack of transparency had eroded trust in SU leadership: “We understand the SU is under financial pressure and the role may need to change, but to find out like this feels as if the rug has been pulled from under us. 

Although the SU has now promised that contracted roles will be available the lack of early communication and consultation left many students feeling uncertain about their future employment. 

Hughes told Palatinate: “Student staff contracts always end in June so there has been no change to anyone’s current employment, but we didn’t make clear what work with guaranteed hours would be available next year before we advertised for casual events staff. 

“We take worker rights and being a good employer seriously, so I’m sorry for this communication mistake which caused understandable confusion.”

Image: Isla Mustin