Student theatre reviews: honesty is never the best policy

By Imogen Usherwood

A “script that should never have been written”, a “wooden performance”, a “rushed and unprofessional” atmosphere. No, it’s not someone feeling especially critical of the new Fantastic Beasts film: all are comments by reviewers from Durham’s various publications for different DST productions in Michaelmas Term. Though, it would be unfair to use these quotes without some much-needed context, namely that such comments are part of thoughtful and (usually) balanced reviews that appreciate the successes and shortcomings of a show.

Ultimately, however, the reviewer has to make a decision; they have to fall on one side or the other. Upon publication, the byline will either read “X is impressed/delighted by …” or “X is disappointed/confused by…”. We need to draw a line when it comes to the tone of reviewing student theatre, and everyone needs to know where it is.

However well-written they might be, by their very nature student reviews are a far cry from professional criticism. Theatre critics make a living attending shows and publishing their thoughts on them, and feel entirely at ease giving their honest opinions about a production. The cast and crew are likely to be strangers, and at any rate the expectation is that they are brutally honest so that theatregoers can make an informed decision to spend their hard-earned savings on that production of Hamlet at the Globe.

Carlos Ebert via Flickr

Student reviews are different, for the simple reason that everyone involved is in the same boat – we are all students. It’s part and parcel of university life; it’s wonderful that anyone can act, write, direct, produce or review at any stage of their university career, regardless of prior experience. But it also means that reviewers come from the same pool of people as actors, directors, producers and writers.

To this end, it’s not the same as professional reviewing, where you can say exactly what you think because it’s no skin off your nose how the director or leading actor feels about your work – you’re just doing your job. As a student reviewer – especially one also involved in DST – chances are that you know somebody involved in the production, or may well get to know them in the not-too-distant future. To that end, it’s worth choosing your words carefully.

However well-written they might be, by their very nature student reviews are a far cry from professional criticism

Another consequence of the student community is that, unlike taking part in a production, there is no audition process or interview for writing reviews; it just wouldn’t be practical to have one, as a small number of people would have to review every show in Durham all year round.

Everyone has to start somewhere, and it means people who have never reviewed before (like me last term) can give it a go and discover something they enjoy – arguably the whole point of university, after all – but it also means that someone with little or no experience of how to write a review, using only a brief online guide to help them, might form a significant part of your show’s publicity, for better or for worse.

Indeed, the function of student reviews is not the same as professional journalism, because the review is as much for the team behind the show as it is for anyone thinking of buying a ticket. Anyone involved in DST will tell you about the suspense of waiting for the reviews the morning after opening night.

Actors and production teams want feedback, constructive criticism and, yes, praise doesn’t go amiss either. Slating a production is utterly unhelpful for the cast and crew, as is a detailed account of ‘What I would have preferred to see…’ or ‘What I would have done…’ (thankfully I haven’t seen a review take that line of argument). Thoughtful, constructive criticism is essential.

There is a line between productive, considerate truthfulness and frank, potentially offensive honesty

This isn’t to say that honesty isn’t important, because a sugar-coated review negates its purpose in every way, but there is a line between productive, considerate truthfulness and frank, potentially offensive honesty. No one who has put weeks of hard work into a two-hour show wants you to tell the entire student community that it was awful; don’t overestimate how thick a person’s skin might be (especially first-time actors or directors), and deal out your criticism with care.

What they want to hear are the relative successes and shortcomings of their play in a polite, gracious article. As a generation so concerned with mental health (and rightfully so), the same rules of watching what you say – and of just being a nice person – in real life still apply in writing. If you wouldn’t say it to their face, don’t say it in your review.

Images: Hernán Piñera via Flickr