Student strikes are a good starting point, but we need political engagement
Natasha Livingstone
“I want you to act as if the house on fire, because it is.” Unless you’ve been living under a rock for the past year, you’ll know these words well. Rightly or wrongly, 16-year-old Greta Thunburg has become the poster girl for the climate movement, with her school strikes kick-starting her fame.
Other well-meaning strikes have been less popular. Extinction Rebellion’s tube protest in London last month damaged much of their popular support. The misdirected effort targeted affordable, and environmentally friendly public transport, making the climate movement appear middle class and out of touch.
Students striking in Durham later this month should bear the errors of Extinction Rebellion in mind. I agree that everyone has the right to strike and it is one of the best features of democracy.
But we have to question whether this particular strike is being organised in the most effective manner and directed at the most critical target.
The whole point of a strike is to cause disruption. Yet we all know that making someone late to work on a low paid, 0-hour contract isn’t going to solve climate change and could reduce support for climate activism.
The relationship between students and Durham locals is already fractious, the organisers need to ensure that this strike will not damage that relationship further. I agree that Durham University should work harder, much harder, to become more sustainable. In the People and the Planet’s environmental ranking, Durham University was rated ‘third class’ for its efforts to limit climate change.
And yes, in theory, the University is accountable to us because we pay the fees: ‘No taxation without representation’ is the democratic basis of the argument. But who represents the students at university? The Students’ Union.
Yet this strike has not been organised with the SU. Instead, the organisers are trying to unite societies to push the strike forward. Perhaps there are valid reasons for not working with the SU, but currently only a few societies have signed up and working with the SU could bring more students into the fold.
I also agree that the greatest power we have over the University are our tuition fees. Surely, then, if we really wanted to force the University to change its ways, we should be pushing for a collective student boycott of such fees?
Naturally, this option is far more radical and harder to organise, but as Greta says, our house is on fire. The organisers are right that we need structural change rather than individual action. Yes, if Durham University became more sustainable, that would have a bigger impact than me ditching plastic for ineffective, package-free deodorant.
But fundamentally, the University is a business operating within a capitalist system with little climate regulation. Surely our focus should be to target Westminster, rather than our University? Strike against the Uni if you wish, but also think about lobbying Durham’s MP, Roberta Blackman-Woods, or getting her involved.
We also have a General Election coming up. Students concerned for the environment should be canvassing for political parties pushing climate reform at the forefront of their manifestos.
Short term profits will continue to be the University’s focus unless there is a significant change in government policy. As an individual, the general election is the biggest opportunity to put the environment in national focus.
Student strikes are a good place to start, but we must go further. Durham University is just the tip of the iceberg, we need to lobby for national, political change.
Illustration by Heidi Januszewski
