Student protests: a review

by Sarah Ingrams

Nicknamed “the Dubstep rebellion” by the BBC’s Newsnight, student protests attracted widespread media attention in the latter months of 2010. Nine months after higher education funding cuts and tuition fees increases were first hinted at in the general election campaign, does the picture for the future of university education look any brighter?

Initial protests

On 10th November, London witnessed the biggest student demonstration in a generation as 52,000 students and lecturers took to the streets in a protest organised by the National Union of Students (NUS) to oppose plans to raise tuition fees and cut higher education funding. Although intended to be peaceful, the day ended with 14 injured and 51 arrested after violence that the Prime Minister condemned as “unacceptable”.

A second demonstration followed on 24th November which will be remembered for the “kettling” of thousands of protesters on Whitehall and charges into the crowd by police on horseback. This time, 153 were arrested.

Meanwhile, across the country, universities staged their own demonstrations. While in Manchester more than 1,000 participated in the protest and a 2,000-strong crowd marched through the centre of Bristol, only an estimated 300 attended the Durham demonstration. As Palatinate concluded on 7th December, “Durham disappoints on day of inaction”.

The decision is announced

The crunch came on 9th December 2010 as the government announced their victory in the House of Commons vote. With a majority of just 21, the coalition’s plans to allow universities to charge up to £9,000 per year and reduce the higher education budget were passed. The controversial vote saw 21 Lib Dem and 6 Tory MPs rebel. Amongst these was Lib Dem MP Greg Mulholland who commented “I am voting against the government today because I simply cannot accept that fees of up to £9,000 are the fairest and most sustainable way of funding higher education”.

Another motion, backed by the same majority, raised the “basic threshold” for fees, currently £3,290, to £6,000 per year from 2012-13.

Once the outcome of the vote became clear, the violence of protesters at Westminster intensified and students smashed windows in the Treasury department.

Despite the violent objections, the proposal was finalised on 14th December as the House of Lords passed the proposal by 68 votes. Labour spokesman Lord Triesman said: “This afternoon’s decision will switch the concept of universities from being a public good, as they have always been through modern history, to essentially a private sector, market-driven by personal private investment.”

Doubts and misgivings

Although Aaron Porter, president of the NUS, argued that the students’ protests had “won the arguments and the battle for public opinion”, many groups have expressed their worries over the future of universities.

In December, the Sutton Trust voiced its concerns that fee rises would make higher education even more inaccessible for the poorest pupils. This is despite the government’s efforts to make opportunities more equal for students of different backgrounds under the National Scholarship Programme for English universities.

Costing £150million per year, the Programme will pay the first year’s tuition fees of student eligible for free school meals.

But the Trust believes that the “reforms amount to a completely new and uncertain landscape for university access for less privileged students.” It fears that there will be little impact on the country’s most prestigious universities outside major urban areas which are infrequently attended by the poorest students.

2011: the difficult year ahead

Trying to allay worries at the beginning of the year, Mr Hughes, the government’s advisor on access to higher education, encouraged universities to be more active in searching for the most intelligent state school pupils. He said that so far they had “failed miserably” in this task.

He continued, “you have gained quite a lot in the settlement.” “You now have to deliver in turn”. But with the teaching grant in England due to be reduced for 2011-12 whilst additional funding from the fees increase is not due until 2012, this year will be a time of hardship for universities.

Professor Steve Smith, President of Universities UK, said that this reduction could be damaging and “result in loss of capacity in some parts of the sector”. He continued: “We would urge the government and the funding council to do what they can to smooth the effects of cuts in grant over this period.”

And the Higher Education Policy Institute’s (Hepi) announcement that “the government’s new proposals are as likely to cost as to save public money” makes the future look even bleaker. The investigation that re-evaluated the government’s plans, in light of concessions made shortly before the vote on the fees increase was decided, concluded that the savings made, if any, would be marginal.

Hepi reported that the annual raising of the repayment threshold “will add substantially to the cost” of the reforms, and “if the earnings increase falls short of the government’s assumptions by just 16%, there will be no savings.”

Following the demonstrations of the past few months, this announcement is rather a bitter pill to swallow.

Institute’s (Hepi) announcement that “the government’s new proposals are as likely to cost as to save public money” makes the future look even bleaker. The investigation that re-evaluated the government’s plans, in light of concessions made shortly before the vote on the fees increase was decided, concluded that the savings made, if any, would be marginal.

Hepi reported that the annual raising of the repayment threshold “will add substantially to the cost” of the reforms, and “if the earnings increase falls short of the government’s assumptions by just 16%, there will be no savings.”

Following the demonstrations of the past few months, this announcement is rather a bitter pill to swallow.