Student politics: a reply
By Joshua Bailey
This week’s Durham Students’ Union elections and the surrounding fallout (http://thetab.com/uk/durham/2016/02/15/jade-26695) have brought into sharp focus the current state of politics in Durham – or rather the lack thereof. We are all acutely aware of the malaise and apathy that casts its shadow over anything ‘political’ in Durham. Turnout in DSU elections is epically low, JCR meetings are scarcely attended and now that I think about it, I don’t think I could name the people on the DSU exec, let alone know what they do. The picture gets even worse when you consider the state of Durham – lowering access provisions, potentially huge changes in the way the University organises, the list goes on. Yet we hear little about these issues on a day-to-day basis and crucially, see even less advocacy, and action, on those issues.
So it seemed odd to me that there was such rancour directed at The Tab’s coverage of the DSU Presidential election. If this is so inconsequential and something Durham students don’t or rather, shouldn’t care about, then why does what The Tab have to say about it matter one iota.
Which brings me to the nub of the issue — whether student journalism should be neutral. Making inaccurate factual claims is one thing (and if The Tab misrepresented Alice or indeed anybody else there should be consequences for that) but I am not sure what the point of editorially neutral student journalism is.
It should be noted that we have already meaningfully crossed the Rubicon on this one. Prominent members of the University community make no pretence at being politically neutral. A week hardly goes by without a JCR President or student journo taking a position on everything from the hiking of college fees to the behaviour of this week’s in-vogue social group/sports team. Given this, I’m not not sure what the big difference is between this and backing candidates – people or groups – is.
But I’ll go further than that. I think that this should be encouraged. When JCR Presidents, student media and for that matter, anybody with a loud enough voice choses to back one candidate or another, it animates the student body. At the very least, it provokes a response from opponents who will jump to defend their position or candidate. That is a healthy process for a student community to go through. That level of of engagement will function to pull the previously apathetic into the conversation. When our attention spans are so short and there are so many different things vying for our attention, we need political people in our community to aggregate the information they have, to help us form opinions and positions on student issues.
People who go to Durham aren’t the BBC. We needn’t demand of them the same standard. They can report the ‘news’ in Durham or chair JCR meetings as they always do; but this way we have a half-decent shot at having a student body that gives a number of s**ts about what goes on here.
What I know for sure is that the silly and hyperbolic rantings of some (http://www.palatinate.org.uk/student-politics-capturing-the-shitegeist/) will do nothing to resolve the situation in which we find ourselves. Because it’s not true that student politics doesn’t matter. Financial support for those who need it is being slashed, rents are climbing at unaffordable rates and disability assistance (mental health provision especially) is woefully accounted for. I know that some get a kick out of putting on their best Peter Hitchens impression and waxing lyrical about how self-indulgent young people are. I wonder whether they realise the irony.
The reality is that lazy attempts to make cheap jokes about “pineapple equality”(http://www.palatinate.org.uk/student-politics-capturing-the-shitegeist/) are self-important and unhelpful when the needs of many sexual, gender and racial minorities are horribly under-appreciated and represented. But I am sure the litany of spoilt brats who think that this kind of thing is clever will continue shouting into the void of their own insignificance. I wish them all the best with it. In the mean time, I look forward to a more politically awake Durham. It’ll be a welcome change from the heady daze we’ve all been in of late.
Photograph: Durham University
