Strength in numbers? The Nicolas and Frances McDowall Collection of British Neo-Romantic Art
By YK Chua
Upon walking through the door of the Durham Art Gallery, I was greeted by a partition wall in the center of the gallery space. The wall was functionally split into two halves, with an introductory text on the left, and an unassuming painting, Alan Reynolds’s Village, October (1953) on the right. Like every other information-craving person today, it was unsurprising that I found myself stood in front of the left side of the wall, reading the descriptive text.
Almost halfway through the text (when I read the words ‘Cubism’ and ‘Expressionism’, reminding me that I am an art history student), I suddenly realised that I had just ignored some beautiful artwork just because the first thing within my immediate vision was a piece of writing.
This instantly raised questions in my mind. Is there a place for explanatory text in a gallery? The tension between requiring someone or something to ‘explain’ an artwork and merely allowing the art to ‘speak to us’ is something that most museums and galleries struggle with. How much text, if any, is appropriate? I find it troubling that the placement of text in exhibitions forces viewers to walk past and ignore works of art, the very objects that we are supposedly there to appreciate.
Accompanying the introductory text on the wall was Village, October, a landscape painting which is very fitting and representative of Neo-Romanticism. The stereotypical examples of Romantic art that many would know are the seascapes and landscapes of Turner and Constable. Reynolds demonstrates the influence of these Romantic landscapes in his work. However, instead of striving for a naturalistic look, Reynolds applies modernist techniques such as Cubism and Expressionism to complete the painting. By the placing of Village beside the introductory text, the audience is immediately made aware, both pictorially and contextually, what the exhibition is about.
As much as Village is a great example of Neo-Romanticism, the artificial lighting cast onto the partition wall, in bid to accentuate the text, compromised the viewer’s appreciation of Reynolds’ painting, reflecting off the oil on board and making the image painful on the eye. Already a relatively dull and gloomy composition, with the majority of the colours used being dark tones, requiring the audience’s attention and patience to appreciate it, the light made concentrating on the picture rather unbearable.
Could such descriptive texts be better positioned so that they complement rather than detract from the art?

The exhibition consists of paintings, drawings and prints from the McDowall Collection. The brilliance of this exhibition is that all the pieces of art are situated in the one room, hung in one line along the walls of the gallery. The audience is able to understand British Neo-Romanticism in its entirety, to appreciate different artists and artworks under a common umbrella term. Because of a lack of narrative, there isn’t a ‘starting picture’ or ‘ending picture’. The effect is that one finds themselves walking around the gallery in circles, absorbing the entire exhibit.
The flipside of having such a layout means that, potentially, individual works start to lose their uniqueness. Works like Keith Vaughan’s Coal Fatigue (1942) and John Elwyn’s Allegory (Mother Earth) (c.1944) are really poignant works of art but because of the hang of the exhibition, it becomes easy for some artworks to be merely glanced over, despite them truly deserving more deliberate contemplation.
I posed a question as the title of this review – ‘Strength in Numbers?’. Is having a large group of work powerful enough that an artistic concept or idea becomes self-explanatory and that text is unnecessary? And, assuming that this could be achieved, what happens to the individuality of each art work if, because of the construct of the exhibition, the viewer fails to give each artwork the attention that it so deserves? It is a difficult question to answer.
The collection is without a doubt a fantastic and extensive one. But I believe that, with the volume it possesses, perhaps, the exhibition could have had a better narrative. However, it was indeed advertised as a ‘The Nicolas and Frances McDowall Collection of British Neo-Romantic Art’, so maybe what is being shown is what it was meant to be after all – just a collection.
The Nicholas and Frances McDowall Collection of British Neo-Romantic Art is on at Durham Art Gallery until 10th January 2016
