State of the Union: necessary and expedient

By Siena Morrell SOTU

In last week’s State of the Union address, Barack Obama presented a humble but positive condition of the nation to a joint session of Congress, focusing on the economic gains achieved during the past year.

The President outlined his legislative agenda for the year ahead, of particular importance given the upcoming mid-term elections in November.

As expected, the economy was the primary focus of Obama’s speech, since polls indicate the economy has been voters’ top priority since last summer.

The President asserted the significance of closing the income inequality gap, by ensuring everyone could aspire to rising income through “ladders of opportunity”. This evocation of the American dream was furthered by claims of the lowest unemployment rate in over five years, and recognition of a “rebounding housing market”. However, the President failed to acknowledge the evidence indicating the lowest labour force participation statistics since 1978.

Obama made clear his preparedness to use executive action to streamline bureaucratic processes in infrastructure projects, and increasing the minimum wage for contracted federal workers.

If passed, these measures would facilitate growth and job creation, though it is unlikely that the Republicans would pass such legislation in an election year. With millions of Americans out of work or struggling to keep up with rising living costs, the promotion of recovery remains a distant prospect.

In a speech characterised by its defiant tone, Obama criticised the Republicans responsible for the government shutdown in October. He reiterated his commitment to “making Washington work better”, and declared that when Congress was slow to legislate, they were “not doing right by the American people”.

By emphasising unilateral action, the President acknowledged his failure to fulfil promises to reverse Washington’s hyper-partisanship.

Despite a gloomy outlook for domestic reform, with limited new policy measures, Obama painted a more positive picture of American foreign policy.

He stressed the end of the war in Afghanistan was indicative of the United States moving away from a “permanent war footing”; however the President ignored the possible deal with Afghan President Hamid Karzai which commits a 10,000-strong residual force to remain in Afghanistan for at least three years. Obama’s restated commitment to the closing of Guantanamo Bay detention camp drew applause from both parties, though he failed to indicate any follow-up plan in the address.

The NSA surveillance scandal, which rocked the world in summer 2013, was granted just a sentence in the speech, indicating an almost complete dismissal of the issue in its entirety. However, the President affirmed the importance of “public confidence” in such programmes, and indicated a vague commitment to reforming measures.

Cathy McMorris Rodgers (R-Wash.), who delivered the Republican response to the address, painted a moderate picture.

The Republicans’ choice to use Rodgers presents a softer image, and an attempt to attract more votes from women in an election year. In a painfully clichéd delivery, with a compassionate emphasis on the family, Rodgers criticised the President for offering big government solutions. “The true state of the Union lies in your heart, and in your home”, Rodgers declared.

Obama largely avoided provocative policies to rile the GOP, with little emphasis on abortion, gun control and immigration. But, the potential for the President to bypass congress led Republican Michele Bachmann, the ‘Queen of the Tea Party’, to call for the President to be sued in the courts, stating, “You don’t make laws without going through the United States Congress. That’s not our system of government and he needs to be held accountable for that”.

Though Obama’s proposed legislation is likely to be less confrontational than the Republicans predict, if the Democrats hope to retain control over the Senate in the mid-term elections, it is essential for the President to fulfil his promises of a “year of action”.

Photograph: Pete Souza/EXOP