Starmer in America
By Matthew Dodd
Marx’s famous idiom tells that history is bound to repeat itself, first as tragedy, then as farce. A British Prime Minister leading a softened Labour Party sits down with a newly-elected populist Republican President and attempts to curry his favour. Smiles abound at a meeting which should, in principle, bring together two very different leaders. It’s a scene which could as easily have taken place twenty years ago as today. It would seem that Marx was indeed onto something, with Starmer and Trump appearing an altogether more farcical pair than their tragic forbears Blair and Bush. “We like each other, frankly, and we like each other’s country”, said the President of the Prime Minister who, in 2016, told the House of Commons he “would not want to have Donald Trump round for dinner”. In cosying up to Trump, Starmer seems to be in danger of retreading the very same path which lead Blair into Iraq and Labour into electoral exile for over a decade.
Tony Blair’s political hamartia was paranoia that his party might be returned to the perpetual opposition they had endured throughout the 80s and 90s. The election of a right wing President in George W. Bush appeared a threat to the liberal consensus of the late 90s, a threat which Blair naturally feared would make its way across the pond. 20 years later, the same pattern is playing out again; the return of Donald Trump to the white house and the rise of the far right throughout the west poses a similar problem for Keir Starmer. With Reform rising in the polls, the far right is making its own waves in Britain, much to the Prime Minister’s evident dismay. Consequently, this attempt to appear on the same page as Trump – offering him an unprecedented second state visit and mirroring his disastrous foreign aid cuts – can’t help but feel like a vain attempt to impress those voters drifting towards Farage’s party.
Keir Starmer has a unique opportunity to present himself as the face of liberal democracy, if only he has the courage to do so
The key difference between Starmer and Blair’s positions, however, is that where Blair had nearly completed a full term before Bush was elected, Starmer has been in post for less than a year. Should he play his cards right, he need not be seeking re-election until 2025, when Trump will, assuming western democracy still stands, be out of office. Starmer’s election in July was something of a last gasp for the brief return to liberal consensus ushered in by Joe Biden’s win in 2020. As European nations are beset by emergent extremists – Meloni in Italy, the perennial threats of Le Pen in France and AfD in Germany – Starmer has found himself in a surprisingly secure position for a centre-left Prime Minister. The sustainability of Reform is as yet uncertain, but given that Nigel Farage has been aligned with three different parties in the last three elections, their viability as a government-forming party in four years’ time should not yet be taken as fact. This is all to say, the Prime Minister is being unnecessarily cautious.
Keir Starmer has a unique opportunity to present himself as the face of liberal democracy, if only he has the courage to do so. Donald Trump’s reckless use of power and his radical alienation of traditional allies has torn the post-word world order to shreds. During his last term, the west looked to figures such as Angela Merkel as an alternative ‘leader of the free world’. This time round, there is no such obvious candidate. The UK has been a waning power for decades now, and Brexit made definite our position as a geopolitical oddity, a strange antique island sitting by itself in the corner of Europe. Here, however, Starmer has a real chance to re-establish Britain’s role as a key diplomatic player on the world stage. Such a notion has been somewhat signalled by the rapid response to Trump’s chaotic meeting with President Zelenskyy, with Starmer assuring the Ukrainian leader that he has “full backing across the UK” days after he’d been publicly harangued by Trump and J.D. Vance.
Diplomacy is a nuanced thing, but there comes a point at which the Prime Minister must decide who and what are our allies and ideals
If this kind of messaging continues and Starmer is prepared to have Britain be an independently-minded nation, not cowering behind its Atlantic neighbour, his tenure may be remembered as key in re-establishing the country’s international standing. It will, however, come down to Keir Starmer’s ability to do the one thing he has most struggled with: coming down off the fence. Diplomacy is a nuanced thing, but there comes a point at which the Prime Minister must decide who and what are our allies and ideals, a point which is rapidly approaching.
Image: Number 10 Downing Street via Wikimedia Commons

