So who audits the auditors?
On the 21st of October the UK Office of Fair Trading (OFT) referred the audit market to the Competition Commission. Auditors are appointed by a company’s shareholders to ensure that the company’s financial statements represent true and fair value of the company. This follows public consultation that opened in 2002 and recently ended in September, where it was deemed that the audit market is too concentrated and uncompetitive, with high barriers to entry.
Whilst 70% of CFOs believe the audit market remains competitive, the Big Four (Ernst & Young, Deloitte, PwC and KPMG) collected 99% of the audit fees for the FTSE 100 in 2010. James Robers, partner of the professional services firm BDO Stoy Hayward, said: “The way the market stands at the moment, it is not a level playing field. There is institutional prejudice against firms outside the Big Four because people stick to the status quo.”
However, PwC boardmember Richard Sexton, said: “There is fierce rivalry as we compete vigorously for audit appointments. All of our audit engagements are for one year only, after which shareholders must vote again to decide on our reappointment.” At the same time, Michael Izza, chief executive of ICAEW, a UK based accounting body, warns the Competition Commission to not forget that UK has very high standards of audit quality which should not be disorted by market intervention.
However it is worth noting that all this comes at a time when the European Commission (EC) looks to legislate on the audit market. OFT’s referral appears to pre-empt and inform the European Commission’s proposals. The EC plans to take a hard line with the Big Four and aims to separate them into smaller audit and non-audit firms to make the market more competitive and reduce conflicts of interest.
There are also plans to introduce compulsory rotation of auditors every eight years, and introduce joint audits between large and small firms. If this draft paper were passed in its entirety it would drastically change the landscape of the audit market and the accounting industry. There are fears that since the Big 4 recruit graduates heavily into their audit divisions, they will be the ones first to feel this change.

