Six Nations preview: England v Scotland

Murrayfield will host this weekend's Calcutta Cup
Murrayfield will host this weekend’s Calcutta Cup

By Harry Thompson

The game in Paris last Saturday marked a clash between two rugby giants: England and France, which thrilled neutrals, delighted the French and left England fans rather puzzled as to what English rugby really looks like at the moment.

We saw a performance with moments of brilliance from the English, witnessing Luther Burrell’s score on debut and some superb sniping breaks from Danny Care, which were matched only by the direct ball carrying from Ben Morgan and Billy Vunipola.

These glimpses were short-lived, however, and often demonstrated a lack of mental fortitude to finish off periods of pressure by the English.

Stuart Lancaster seems to have chosen a side full of variety but lacking in composure. His decision to start Jack Nowell, at only twenty years of age for his first cap, received lots of press attention in the build up to the game, but the only general consensus by half-time was a feeling of pity from England fans.

We must hope that this championship will not be the lethal injection for a young talent which has flourished in the Premiership but may now be tarnished through premature exposure, much like Danny Cipriani’s 2008 Six Nations.

Perhaps this is too critical an assessment of Nowell, he did carry well at times but he also  seemed flustered and indecisive compared to France’s Gael Fickou, whose last-gasp finish marks a nineteen year-old with exceptional composure.

Nevertheless, Nowell has secured his second start ahead of Saturday’s clash against Scotland and England will be hoping that he can get himself into the game early on with some secure carrying, rather than the anti-climax last week which saw him drop the starting kick-off.

The England side remains unchanged following the French defeat which seems understandable as Lancaster needs to build confidence within what remains a very inexperienced team, particularly in the backs.

England will hope to continue to see the centre partnership flourish, as it looked firm in defence and occasionally explosive in attack, with Burrell offering a hard-yards alternative to Twelvetrees’ distribution skills.

“The battle will be won through the centre channels”

Across the back-three England will be hoping that Brown can guide the inexperienced Nowell through his second cap unscathed and that Jonny May will be able to get some front-foot ball from which he can launch some of his characteristically slippery runs around the Scottish defence.

In the pack work has to be done on the set-pieces which were far from perfect against France and may become an area of immense importance against Scotland who are used to playing quite tight in attack.

In my opinion, however, the battle will be won through the centre channels; Scotland are currently looking to expand their game, while England are trying out new combinations in preparation for the 2015 home World Cup.

If the Twelvetrees-Burrell partnership can contain Scotland’s powerful runners, such as David Denton and Ross Ford who will be running off nine and then, without leaving too much space for Hogg to target Nowell and May, then England stand a strong chance of clinching a hard-fought victory at Murrayfield.

It will be a close game on Saturday, but in my opinion it will be England to win by six points.

England v Scotland kicks off on Saturday at 17:00

Photograph: Ian McIver