Six Nations blog: you can’t always trust the stats
A well-known quote, popularized by Mark Twain, asserts that ‘there are three kinds of lies: lies, damned lies, and statistics.’
Indeed, looking at the data from the second act of this year’s Six Nations alone, you’d be forgiven for believing that the hosts emerged victorious in Dublin and that the Azzurri took the points at Murrayfield.
Both Ireland and Italy claimed 60% of the possession and territory in their encounters, winning twice as many rucks as their opponents and conceding fewer penalties.
Despite all this, Lancaster’s accomplished England dampened Irish spirits at a sodden Aviva, and the Scots produced a record-breaking performance to demolish the on-form Italians with a new-found intensity.
Not just that, but Wales – on a run of ten successive defeats – defied the bookmakers with a rare victory in Paris. The predicted French backlash never materialized.
How did it happen? Well, the English win could have been anticipated; off the back of a comfortable win at HQ, the fearless young side were not burdened by the weight of history that a visit to Dublin often brings.
With talisman O’Driscoll perhaps distracted by the arrival of his first child, and key names Sexton and Zebo injured early on, the Irish possession failed to count.
The mature approach of Lancaster’s men to the miserable conditions was perhaps unattractive, but prioritising effectiveness allowed them to break a long-running Dublin jinx. This leaves England the only unbeaten side, and firm favourites for the championship.
Wales may have a decisive say in the outcome though, having heaped more pressure on a French outfit that has yet to turn up. However, to win in Rome will require another composed performance from Ospreys stand-off Biggar, and Justin Tipuric will hope to take advantage of an Italian back-row without the talismanic Parisse.
If Wales can rediscover last year’s title-winning attitude and lose their recent crippling malaise, a visit to Cardiff may yet prove to be England’s toughest test.
That is not to say that England will stroll it this weekend – the new personnel in a much-changed French side will feel they have a massive point to prove at Twickenham, with Philippe Saint-André encouraging his squad to ‘be French – audacious and unpredictable’.
Expect to see a much-improved level of game management through the revised half-back pairing of Parra and Trinh-Duc, who are unlikely to surrender as meekly as Michalak and Machenaud did to the Italians.
Also look out for huge impacts in midfield as Manu Tuilagi meets the giant Mathieu Bastareaud. An English win is the prediction, but it would be naïve to think a runaway victory more likely than a tense finale.
Scotland will welcome the depleted Irish next week with renewed enthusiasm, having quietened a confident Italy with four scintillating tries.
Their say in the competition is far from over, with head coach Scott Johnson proclaiming, “we’re back in this tournament; we’re in it up to our eyeballs!” – and I think they might sneak another win here.
Predictions:
ENG v FRA: England by seven
SCO v IRE: Scotland by less than seven
ITA v WAL: Wales by two scores
Photograph: George Olcott

