Signifying nothing: the films of the Coen Brothers
By Jonathan Peters

“Life’s but a walking shadow, a poor player that struts and frets his hour upon the stage, and then is heard no more. It is a tale told by an idiot, full of sound and fury, signifying nothing” – William Shakespeare, Macbeth
The Coen Brothers’ latest film tells the story of Llewyn Davis, a struggling 1960s folk singer trying to make it in the Greenwich Village music scene. Llewyn drifts around for the majority of the film’s running time, and although we witness his encounters with various record label execs and fellow artists, the directing duo eschew a traditional narrative structure. The film moves episodically – Llewyn comes across an opportunity, ventures dangerously close towards success, before his pride, or the machinations of some other character, get the better of him. There is no triumphant last scene for Llewyn where he strikes a record deal, rather he continues to wander, and the final reel of the film could be spliced into the first to create a perfect loop.
The atmosphere of the film is one of despair, of entrapment in an unstoppable cycle of failure. Llewyn is stubborn and will never turn his back on his dreams, but the world will always remain entirely ambivalent to his talent. As he stands alone down a dark alley at the end of film, beaten and bruised, there is a sense of the futility of existence, of life as signifying nothing.
The Coen Brothers have dabbled in many genres, from gangster to spy film to modern western, but they all follow the same pattern as Inside Llewyn Davis, where we are forced to question at the end the meaning, or meaninglessness, of what we just watched. The plot of screwball comedy classic The Big Lebowski is calculatedly overblown and complex, yet the catalyst event – the kidnapping of Bunny and cutting off of her toe – is revealed to be entirely fictitious by the time the credits roll, a ruse that nevertheless drew all the characters into a narrative of unnecessary death and carnage.
Equally, whilst the central motifs of The Big Lebowski are a urine-stained rug and the severed toe, the motif of Burn After Reading is a CD, supposedly full of CIA data, but actually containing an insignificant memoir. Once again false meaning is attached to something useless, and once again blood is shed, in a barrage of entertaining sound and fury, ultimately for no real reason.
However, the universe for the Coen Brothers is not a godless place, where human beings destroy each other over nothing and prayers for salvation remain unanswered. Clearly fate is at work in Fargo, where every character who displays traces of greed and selfishness ends up lying in a pool of blood (or a woodchipper), whilst Marge Gunderson, the warm, compassionate and altruistic heart of the film, emerges unscathed.
The Coen Brothers do not shy away from representing metaphysical concepts in their films. Charlie Meadows in Barton Fink, Anton Chigur in No Country for Old Men, and Lorne Malvo in the recent Fargo TV adaptation (not created by the Coen Brothers but naturally heavily inspired by them) are villains who are clearly not of this world, but manifestations of evil.
Anton Chigur in particular appears to be an emissary of Satan, his background and motives unexplained, but whenever he appears onscreen death is not far behind. He crosses the desert murdering people who are unable to escape their destiny – after several tense escapes and nail-biting action scenes the audience assumes that protagonist Llewellyn Moss has escaped from his clutches, but then he is murdered offscreen two thirds of the way through the film. Unlike in Fargo, the assigning of fate to characters in No Country for Old Men seems far more random. Chigur decides on his victims using a coin toss, regardless of the innocence or guilt of the character on the receiving end of his killing contraption.
If the films of the Coen Brothers can be brought together to reveal a coherent worldview at all, they show life as a constant bitter and brutal struggle, often for the sake of nothing in particular. The directors do not dwell in the realm of the absurd – fate is shown to be at work, far beyond the control of any of the characters. However, whilst it recognises good, it also rewards evil, and seems to operate randomly and in a manner that is indifferent to man’s suffering.
