Should we listen to past political leaders?

By Bartosz Maj

One does not have to hold the position of Prime Minister to voice a political opinion. Memoirs or books by past national leaders are not a new phenomenon; leaders or key figures from previous administrations have not simply faded into irrelevance, and for good reason. A democracy does not consist of a single job, and we should not tie one’s ability to contribute to the political atmosphere to the arbitrary metric of whether they previously inhabited a leadership position.

However, even though we should not simply erase them from the political world, we should consider the relevant biases in their writings or messages. World leaders leave behind legacies, and these legacies will shape how history looks at them and how future generations judge their governance. Therefore, we should acknowledge that what they say may be a mere attempt to shift the narrative.

Key figures from previous administrations have not simply faded into irrelevance, and for good reason.

Nevertheless, the need to judge people according to their supposed biases is not a reason to send them into political exile. After all, in a society of parties and representative democracy we must all pay at least a little attention to every political figure’s many biases and self-interests, current or past.

Previous leaders were elected for a reason. These may be their long list of competencies, legislative successes or a message which resonated with the public. These don’t simply stop being relevant because eight years have passed, or the electorate lost faith. Past leaders offer their pre-governmental qualifications and all the experience they amassed during their time in office, and there is no reason to ignore these, simply because they no longer occupy their central position.

That being said, not all ex-leaders should be listened to. Not all declines are equal. Sometimes key political figures leave due to term limits or personal reasons, but others are voted out, pushed away by the public or their parties because of their failures. A past leader should be judged on the basis of their deeds and their ideas. We should be looking at who this person is, and what they bring to the table, and if the nature of their exit from a leading position offers reasons for exclusion, then so be it, but the simple fact they once inhabited the job is not enough of a reason to ignore them.

We fail to appreciate the plurality of politics and how many voices are involved

This highlights a wider issue in modern politics: the constant need to stand behind someone. The outstanding individual who will look good on the campaign poster and give good soundbites on the debate summary uploaded to YouTube the next day. The media and the public need to have a single person to look up to, and a single person to bring down when everything goes wrong. The spotlight doesn’t have room for the thousands of advisors, policy planners, academics and civil servants who contribute to the running of governments, meaning we think we need a strong individual to lead us, and any other voices don’t deserve consideration.

The historical trend of defining politics by the “great men” of history continues to rear its head as we fail to appreciate the plurality of politics, and how many different voices build campaigns, governments, agencies or slogans. Our need to pin vast policy infrastructures and governmental frameworks on an individual and throw them away into obscurity shows how our relationship with democracy is not one which appreciates the significance of plurality in our system and how much we need it.

Photography: Dippydy via Flickr.