Should we leave Post (M)alone?
By Tom Watling
Post Malone is the centre-piece of this article for two reasons. Firstly, because, following his almost instantaneous success, instigated by ‘White Iverson’, now quadruple platinum, justified by ‘Stoney’, now double-platinum, and solidified by ‘Beerbongs & Bentleys’, Grammy-nominated, double-platinum and top of the charts, he is at the forefront of Hip Hop. Secondly, because, according to John Caramanica of the New York Times, he is a white, “face-tattooed onetime folk singer who has become a kind of post-rap incantation specialist.”
Eminem may have been the first white person to popularise rap, and indeed the first rapper to exponentialize demand for the genre, but Post Malone is the face of the second-wave, twice as removed from the origins of the genre he stands to represent and thus twice as problematic. It is not surprising, then, that the only thorn in the side of his monumental success is the accusation of cultural appropriation, and the intermittent cries from his detractors denouncing him as no more than a ‘culture vulture’.
It is not surprising, then, that the only thorn in the side of his monumental success is the accusation of cultural appropriation
Post Malone appears to be the perfect phenotype of the successful musician, hard-working, melodic, laconic and white, and the rapidity of his growth attests to this, but to what extent is his success to the detriment of the genre he operates within?
At this juncture, it is necessary to say that I am not primarily concerned with the impact of trap music on the genre of Hip Hop so much as I am concerned with the coalescent effect of trap music and white success on the genre of Hip Hop. Though there may be recourse to suggest that trap music alone is problematic, such an argument is far too equivocal and multifaceted to be broached in article format. Fittingly, then, I want only to explore the success of white rappers, in particular the success of Post Malone, within the general purview of trap music.
Messages of minority-empowerment cannot survive popularisation in this current climate.
In this climate of ‘fake-news’ and insoluble realities, enmeshed within a post-racial outlook typified by terms such as ‘colour-blindness’ and ‘meritocracy’ and delimited by a self-regulating free-market, it is oftentimes impossible to propose arguments that do not simply fall upon the deaf ears of those who disagree with you. And nowhere is this more evident than arguments claiming the negative effect of whiteness on a market understood simply as the amoral sum of its transactional participants.
A market dominated by white people will more often than not yield results for white people, and the music industry is no different. Consumer culture is, for the most part, white, and it is far easier for a white consumer to relate to a white artist (seller) than to someone of a different colour. Neoliberal market principles, alongside a post-racial outlook characterised by ‘racism without the racists’, exacerbate white success and therefore whiteness as the norm. Consumers are not racist for gravitating toward white artists; the system within which they operate ensures that they remain ignorant to the racist consequences of their own actions.
The longer Post is scapegoated for issues far greater than himself, the longer his success will prevail.
In relation to Hip-Hop, a genre that was started by African-Americans and may be considered an instrumental tool for their (self-)empowerment, it could be said, then, that its success was capped from the beginning. The neoliberal climate in which it entered, and the post-racial climate in which it (inadvertently) helped to create, ensured that either it was limited to subcultural influence, afforded the ability to empower only on a relatively miniscule stage, or metastasized to such a degree that the message of empowerment was inevitably diluted, even perhaps purloined, by an array of white imitators, imposters or assimilators popularised, at least partially, as a result of their white skin. That is not to say that Hip Hop was given the choice to stay underground or go mainstream, that is a choice available only to individuals, but that these were the only two outcomes possible. Messages of minority-empowerment cannot survive popularisation in this current climate.
So, should we leave Post alone? Well, no, but to concentrate criticism on white rappers alone is tantamount to attacking only the foot-soldier; it is only one small part of toppling the army. Post is not a thoughtless product of the neoliberal, post-racial system – his comments denouncing the emotivity and power of Hip-Hop exemplify this – but he isn’t the cause of it either. He is merely a symptom. It is the neoliberal free-market, the post-racial climate and the befogging of the truth that require more thorough reproach. The longer Post is scapegoated for issues far greater than himself, the longer his success will prevail.
Photo by The Come Up Show via Flickr
