Should we give controversial political figures a platform at universities?

By Daria Solomatina

The views expressed in this article are those of the author and not necessarily of Palatinate.

 

Last week on Thursday more than 200 protesters assembled outside of the Oxford Union, where the leader of the French far-right ‘Front National’ Party – Marine Le Pen – was invited to give a speech in front of Oxford University students. Protesters condemned the Union for inviting an apparently ‘fascist’ and ‘nazi’ politician, chanting “Nazi scum, here we come” and “Oxford Union, shame on you”. The demonstration did not stop there, with some of the crowd going on to climb over the fence into the Union yard. This delayed Mrs Le Pen’s appearance by more than an hour.

By definition, freedom of speech involves the absence of state interference and protection by law of the expression of one’s own opinion without being harmed or otherwise threatened. And if the individuals who attended the protest are afforded this luxury, Marine should be too, along with all of the students who were told to stay inside the Debating Chamber for ‘[their] own safety’. Free speech is free speech.

But does Mrs Le Pen’s ideology impinge on our rights as citizens? OUSU (Oxford University Students Union) wrote an open letter, sent on the day of the event, asking the Union to forbear inviting controversial speakers in future: “The views of people such as Marine Le Pen are so troubling, so dangerous and so extreme that we believe that in giving them a platform the Oxford Union, far from aiding the cause of free speech, in fact harms it by contributing to the intimidation of oppressed groups.” Marine’s ‘bigoted’ talk brings divisive politics into our community.

Undoubtedly, her views are atrocious and unacceptable to most of the people in this country, but is that a reason good enough to ignore her? By denying her the platform to speak and get her views challenged we are not reducing hatred, we are acknowledging our inability to face her in a free and open debate.

Marine didn’t come to Riyadh or Kabul, where she would be met with a bit more than just ‘peaceful protest’, but she came to a world-class university, to speak in front of clearly critical and reasonable students, who should be encouraged to tackle such ideas, rather than being patronized and guarded from them.

It is already regrettable to witness how far we have fallen: the questions from the floor and all of the President’s questions focused mainly on Jean-Marie Le Pen’s ideas and Marine’s support for her father’s ideology, with one lady raising up to make sure Mrs Le Pen realized the students didn’t come to the Union to support her (as if any of us would be voting in 2017 elections in France). This was a clear demonstration of the audience’s exceptional misunderstanding of Marine’s position, inability to think on the spot and assess her arguments clearly, but moreover an utter reluctance to even listen to what the speaker had to say. The arguments were personal and unconstructive.

Protestors claimed that by allowing the figures like Marine to appear at the Union, the university is legitimizing her views. This said, Marine is already a massively acknowledged politician – a week ago her party came top in the first round of a French parliamentary byelection, and if the general vote were to take place today she would become a new President of the Fifth Republic. Is the ‘Union-granted’ legitimacy is something she came to Oxford for? We do not claim that Ian McKellan’s or Morgan Freeman’s appearances at the Union make them famous and publicly recognized figures.

The protest is good as it expresses the opportunity of all and everyone to voice their views, but it does not mean we have to close down the debate and silence ‘controversial’ speakers.

 

Marine Le Pen

If you would like to express a different view to that of this author, please email in a contribution to politics@palatinate.org.uk

Photograph: The Guardian