Should we buy into this Brand of revolution?

By James Kessell
For those of you that haven’t watched Russell Brand’s entertaining skirmish with Paxman, allow me to summarise.
Brand wants a revolution, but he doesn’t know how. He wants to replace government but he doesn’t know what with. Maybe something like ‘admin-bods’. He has never voted, but isn’t apathetic. He’s worth £9 million, but thinks profit is a really bad thing. He speaks for the working man and says ‘ain’t’ and ‘innit’ a lot. Oh, and he likes Paxman’s beard.
Praise has been heaped on Brand across Facebook and Twitter newsfeeds this week for speaking out against this evil ‘system’ that only serves a tiny proportion of people. Aren’t we all lucky to have such a genuine and insightful figurehead to lead this revolution against oppression.
Hang on. Politics isn’t Star Wars. There isn’t some sort of evil force trying to screw everyone over.
Our democratic system had been honed over centuries. It is the bulwark against oppression, the channel though which peaceful and rational change can be wrought in the interests of everyone.
Brand argues that the burden of proof – the burden of justification for this revolution – isn’t on him, it’s on “the people with the power.” Well, let’s compare the proof for the ‘system’ that exists today against the realities of ‘Brand’s revolution.’
There has arguably never been a better time or place to be living than in modern day Britain. The ‘indifferent system’ provides us with education, welfare, free healthcare, security, democracy, justice… The list goes on. Every citizen has equal rights, freedom, and an equal share of the vote. Sure, there are flaws, but what would the alternative look like?
Revolution would be terrifying, leaving hundreds of thousands without food, shelter and healthcare. It would be violent, it would be bloody, and, when we look at the socialist revolutions of the past, this egalitarian revolution would establish a dictatorial big man in the place of the democratic system which we ought to treasure.
If people need any more persuasion away from grandiose revolutionary action without any rational idea of the system that they’re trying to establish, then they only have to look across to the potent current examples of Syria and Egypt.
But, to be frank, a revolution is not on the cards. We will not be facing a bloody socialist revolution headed by a shaggy comedian wearing a £2000 outfit. What then is the significance of Brand’s trumpeted arguments? Is he simply a well-publicised, narcissistic jester who creates entertaining but nonsensical diversions when the questioning gets tough?
The answer is yes, but the significance of his arguments broadcast across the globe is far greater than their minimal intellectual clout. What is damaging is the effect that his superficial but emotive brand of passionate apathy may have upon those who are at the bottom of society, hard up and already disenchanted with ‘the system.’
It gives them a quasi-intellectual justification for doing even less to improve their lot and engaging even less with the institutions that have the power to change things for them – education, jobcentres, and on a greater scale – political elections.
The last thing that those in what Brand calls the “underclass” need is to further distance themselves from the ‘system’ and the channels through which personal, regional and national change is wrought. If a certain section of society fail to exercise their hard-won democratic right to vote then it is inevitable that the ‘system’ will fail to represent their needs. What is needed is a greater engagement with the ‘system’ for those who feel disenfranchised, not less.
The British status quo isn’t perfect and Brand’s calls for change do have some fundamental validity. However the only effective and rational way to bring about this change is through our democratic system.
For Brand to encourage an apathetic approach to voting is not only juvenile and ill-considered, but downright damaging for those most receptive to his arguments.
Photograph: Duncan Hall
