Should students be allowed to cast their vote at university?

Students should be allowed to vote in their university constituencies

Thom Addinall-Biddulph

I should begin this article with that perennial favourite of comment, ‘full disclosure’. I have already voted at university, specifically indeed in Durham. Not in a general election; I didn’t turn eighteen until September 2006, far too late for the last election. However, I did vote in the 2008 election for the unitary authority, in Elvet ward (for the Liberal Democrats, should you be interested). I also fully intend to vote in the City of Durham constituency on 6th May this year, assuming that is when the general election shall be held.

I do not believe that I am doing anything wrong by doing this. Firstly, I’m applying for a PhD and will most likely be here for a long time to come anyway, but even if I were, say, graduating in July, I would still vote here. This stems partly from a fundamental problem in our system of government.

We do not have separation of powers in the United Kingdom, that is to say a fully separate executive and legislature, as the United States has. There are both advantages and disadvantages to this state of affairs, into which this is not the place to go.

The upshot, though, is that you are voting simultaneously, with only one vote, for your local MP and for the national government.

There is a strong argument that, were we voting merely for a local MP, students should not be allowed to vote at university (unless, of course, they live in the same constituency as their university), as the vast majority of us are here for only three or four years. But this is not the case: we are voting also for the party we want to form the executive.

There are significant issues with this; you might want Labour in power nationally, but detest your local Labour candidate, and have a dedicated, hard-working Conservative MP whom you wish to support.
In my case, my home constituency is Finchley and Golders Green, part of which used to be Margaret Thatcher’s seat. It unexpectedly went Labour in 1997, and remained so in 2001 and 2005. However, the incumbent MP is, wisely, standing down and, thanks to boundary changes, the seat is notionally Conservative.

I am a committed Liberal Democrat, and it is entirely pointless to vote Lib Dem at home- it’s a straight Tory-Labour fight, which Mike Freer, the extremely unpleasant Conservative, will win.
In Durham, though, the Tories stand no hope, whereas the Lib Dems have a real chance of defeating Labour. Even one seat could make a vital difference to the national picture: for my party, every extra seat makes us stronger, especially in the event of a hung Parliament.

Though it is a nice idea, the simple fact of the matter is I am not voting just for the candidate I think will represent Durham best, and be the best constituency MP. I am voting for someone who will not only deal with the bin on Gilesgate that has not apparently been emptied this year, but will also cast a vote on issues of great national importance, up to and including war. I am not defending the system as it is, but it is not about to change, and these are national issues on which I can vote from wherever I am in the country.

I would have absolutely no problem with someone born and brought up in Durham, living in student accommodation in Golders Green, and voting for Mike Freer.

Arguments against students voting at university also tend to assume students are inherently ignorant and local-wary, and will vote without a care for their university town.
That may be true of some of us. But if we were to disallow anyone who does not think properly before voting, we would disenfranchise, I suspect, rather a lot of people, most of whom mean perfectly well.

The way we seek to reach those who vote for the BNP is to reveal the hollow, ugly core of the party and the benefits of what they oppose. There is no reason why we could not make a similar effort to make sure students know what local issues are, and to think about them as well as national policy when voting. Besides which, we do actually live here, and many of us know very well what issues the town faces, because after all we are students- we are quite likely to be politically-aware, and my opponent in this debate will not be the only person to think about the other residents of Durham.
Finally, we must also remember that, considering that we are voting on national issues, we are voting on behalf of students. We may not be students for much longer, but a new class begins every year, for whom we should have some concern.

There were university constituencies in the past, but there are none these days, so we cannot vote in a ‘student constituency’ per se. If we only vote at home, who is going to vote on behalf of students? In student towns, candidates know they have to appeal to students; if we all voted solely at home, no one would give a second thought to the needs of students (again, in the USA this might be different because of the wider prevalence of local community colleges).

Higher education is vital to our society for a host of reasons, not least economically-speaking, and so it is important that we remain as a clear constituency that candidates must pay attention to, as indeed our candidates here in Durham are. I do not mean to suggest all students must vote at university, but at the very least it is right to give us the option. For many students, voting in your university town will be far more useful than voting at home.


Students should only be allowed to vote at home

Freddie Myles

I recently attended a documentary screening, which included footage of Gala Day in 1960’s Durham. Bathed in midsummer sun, mining communities marched through the same streets that I would cross on the way home. Proud families laughed, looked on, collected at the Racecourse Grounds to listen to and cheer Harold Wilson standing up for the workers, standing up for the Durham pits.

Now, if we care to look at the sheaves of election literature left unclaimed in student mailboxes, we find candidates campaigning to keep middle-class students’ higher education (H.E) fees down.
We find candidates promising to spend more time than ever promoting student politics, promising to make traffic by-law changes around the Union key policies. Who can blame them? This is simply savvy electioneering on the candidates’ parts, with every Durham student automatically added to the local electoral roll.

A few hours of photos-ops with the student council might stick in the minds of whichever students remember to drop into the church hall on 6th May. But this isn’t representing the community, nor is it promoting the best interests of the people of this city. Students’ concerns can be better represented by their voting at home; the Durham politicians should be the concern of the Durham residents. Students pass through, usually, for three years, and take little or no part in the functions that matter politically. Students do not pay more than minimal tax in Durham, and do not receive state benefits.

Issues of H.E funding have nothing particularly to do with the interests of Durham, and can be as well-voiced from any other corner of the nation. The infrastructure of the city, the public spaces and retail outlets, will not have to be lived with for the rest of the students’ lives. Take the case of the new Tesco, permitted to open on Silver Street over the past summer (this may not strictly be the territory of the MP, but my argument also applies to the council).

For passing students, all told here for perhaps eighteen months, this was a convenient slice of metropolitan life amongst what can seem, for students raised in larger cities, a rather lacklustre choice of shops. Let us say, for argument’s sake, that this Tesco was destined to push the other grocers around the town centre out of business. Whose voice should matter more when Tesco applies for its retail license? The sellers of Durham market, whose families have lived in the area for generations and who themselves will keep a stall until retirement? Or students? Durham is a working class city; the student body in Durham is predominantly middle class.

Surely the MP representing Durham should reflect the values of those who live here their whole lives, rather than support the interests of those whose income support (i.e. Daddy) likely lives outside of the constituency?

This relates to a wider problem in Durham; that of the lack of the respect that is shown, often unintentionally, from the students to those who make Durham their permanent home.

I recognise that years of work have been put in to lessen the friction of the home-counties invasion, and I understand that much of this effort has been successful. Nevertheless, seeing boys across Market Square in their pyjamas pulling each other’s trousers down for laughs, or girls telling the shopkeeper she has a lovely accent in their most patronising voices possible, is not an edifying sight. Students at Durham should, when matriculating, be given information about the city they have come to live in. They should be informed of its history, the foundations of its peoples, its values.

Students can form a major role in a vibrant community; providing fresh voices and views, motoring the economy, keeping the streets full of energy. But they also must remember; we are only visitors here. We do not have as much right to the future of Durham as those who live here, those whose views should be represented in parliament.

Yes, of course the university is a huge part of the community, and the economic hold it has in so far as the staff who live here lend it a great importance to the area. The interests of the university rightfully remain significant in any election campaign, via interests of the not-always -fantastically-paid local staff members who work and run the institution across decades of intakes. But a student’s interests, at any one particular time, do not deserve precedence.

This is not to say students do not deserve a voice in the city. My argument is rather that this should come through the conduit of the interests of the enduring power bloc that is the university administration. At the documentary I attended, residents evoked their own memories of past Gala days. They told touching stories of afternoons in the sunshine, on crowded streets, celebrating their city. Then, one voice, “it was a wonderful time, they were our streets then”. An audible groan of agreement ran through the audience. I felt embarrassed, and humbled. The city of Durham deserves an M.P. who can represent its true, permanent interests.

If you have not already, I urge you to switch your residence in the electoral register to your home constituency. I have already done so, and look forward to welcoming Durham’s next M.P., who I am sure will treat all visiting students with the hospitality characteristic of Durham’s people.