Should Birmingham City have hired Wayne Rooney?

By Joe Harston

Upon the dissolution of the Championship for yet another early season international break, Birmingham City’s popular new American ownership group – fronted by the face of Tom Brady – executed the shock sacking of manager John Eustace in favour of Wayne Rooney as his replacement.

Under previous ownership, The Blues have had an unenviable experience in the second tier – laden with fan protests for several seasons. Since being relegated from the Premier League in 2011, Birmingham have finished in the playoffs just once – and that was in 2012. Now, they are on a streak of seven seasons finishing towards the foot of the table, with last season’s 17th placed finish being their highest in that period.

So after a summer transfer window that the usual promotion chasers can be jealous of, John Eustace’s men shot out of the traps. With new boys Jay Stansfield and Siriki Dembele starring in attack, they sat in sixth placeat the time of the sacking.

From a footballing perspective, there seems very little to gain from this

Since the takeover, the work of the new owners must be commended.

To say recruitment has been savvy would be an understatement, with Ethan Laird, Lee Buchannan and Cody Drameh vastly improving their options at full- back; they also made permanent last season’s impressive loanees Krystian Bielik and Dion Sander- son.

Generally around the club, the atmosphere has improved dramatically, with the new owners playing the PR game perfectly – from stadium improvements to Brady buying drinks for fans in a local pub one matchday – however, one can’t help but wonder whether Eustace’s sacking and Rooney’s subsequent hiring is one PR move too far.

In the unceremonious sacking, which seems to be down to owner Tom Wagner, the club emphasised the responsibility of their management to adopt a “no fear playing style”. This feels insulting to Eustace – whose teams characteristically play with attacking fullbacks and fluid attacking patterns with recruitment supporting this recently. Such ambiguous wording to attempt to justify such a bizarre decision hasn’t sat right with fans and neutrals alike and without sounding too unfair it seems to be quite fitting of the archetypal American football club owner.

CEO, Garry Cooke went on to release a statement defending the decision of the owners to the fans. He said that while Eustace had clear and ambitious goals for the season, a series of meetings highlighted a clear “misalignment with leadership at the Club.” He went on to remind fans of the work done so far by the owners and the commitment of the Board to create long-term success for the club among other outrage-muting cliches.

Such a strong start leaves him with what is the most pressurised job of his short managerial career

Rooney comes fresh from a disappointing stint in America with DC United where he fled from Derby County when their own American takeover fell through post-relegation.

Rooney’s time at Derby and their valiant effort to stay up despite a 21-point deduction for both entering administration and breaching financial fair play laws, will no doubt be the ulterior reason for his appointment other than his huge profile as a player beingextremely marketable overseas.

From a footballing perspective, there seems very little to gain from this. He goes into the role boasting a meagre 28% win rate across his two prior jobs and a playing identity that hardly fits the ‘winning culture’ and ‘no fear play style’ that the Blues’ owners claim to prioritise in their recruitment process. Furthermore, Rooney’s right- hand man from his days at Pride Park, Liam Rosenior has moved on rather successfully. Rosenior temporarily took the reins at Derby before moving on to Hull City where he is enjoying a season comparable to that of Birmingham with ambitious signings and an uncharacteristic playoff push.

So without what could’ve possibly been the brains of the operation, this appointment may carry more risk than initially anticipated.

It very much seems to be a case of ‘if it’s not broke don’t fix it’ and with the majority of the season still to play, it would of course be unfair to write off Rooney and co so early but what is for sure is that such a strong start leaves him with what is the most pressurised job of his short managerial career.

Image: Fitzyt via Wikimedia Commons