Shoelaces: it’s knot what you think
By Tarek Schoehl
What connects the flower of the bastard hogberry, light, and mathematics? Knots, of course! A recent study has revealed that the flower of the bastard hogberry, a plant native to Central and South America, has a complex surface structure that gives it special properties which makes its surface reflect light in a special pattern. Researchers were able to use this optical phenomenon and adapt it to plastic fibres, resulting in a fibre that changes colour when under stress.
This development allows mathematicians to directly observe the amount of tension a knot is experiencing, offering a way to check if their calculations match reality. This ability also applies to knots such as your shoelaces and sailor’s knots. Using these newly developed fibres one can easily rank knots according to strength even if they are very difficult to understand from a knot theoretical point of view. Using this experimental data, the researchers were able to come up with new simulations and models to describe knots, findings which they hope will soon help them find new ways to tie and twist them. But why do we even care about knots?
What connects the flower of the bastard hogberry, light and mathematics?
We learn how to knot You may have heard of a somewhat well-known example our shoelaces when we’re young and we remember for the rest of our lives, yet it all becomes muscle-memory, and we don’t have to give it a second thought. But in fact, there is a whole area of mathematical research dedicated to knots: ‘Knot Theory’.
But what are the differences between your shoelaces and a ‘mathematical knot’? What a mathematician calls a ‘knot’ slightly differs from our everyday experience. See, ‘knot theory’ is a subfield of topology, a field in mathematics where you study the dynamics of geometric objects like a sphere or a doughnut. In these studies, you allow the shape of the objects to deform and stretch, as if they were made of Play-Doh.
You may have heard of the somewhat well-known example that topologically speaking a doughnut is equivalent to a mug, because both of them only have one hole and you can deform the mug continuously into a doughnut (very funny, I know). Anyhow, the point is that if you are allowed to deform and change the object, for example shoelaces, you can easily undo the knot and are left with essentially just a long piece of string. Because of this, mathematicians require their knots to be closed, so if you want to think of your tied shoelaces as a ‘mathematical knot’ you would have to glue the loose ends together.
Knots are not as useless as they may seem
Knots have been of interest to humans since the dawn of time for various reasons. They were used to tie things, record information and they were aesthetically pleasing. Later on, sailors were required to know a whole array of knots, each one having a different purpose due to its strengths and weaknesses.
The mathematical theory of knots would have to wait until the late 1700s when Alexandre Théophile Vandermonde first noted properties of knots connecting them to topology. Since then there has been tremendous progress in the field: there are several different criteria by which you can tell if two seemingly different knots are actually identical, and there have been great efforts in trying to classify as many knots as possible.
Knot theory has hugely benefited from the invention of the computer, which allows mathematicians to compute more and more difficult knot invariants and even use neural networks to automatically classify knots. Knots also play an important role in biology, helping to understand how DNA and proteins twist and unravel. We’ve been steadily realising that knots are not as useless as they may seem, and interesting findings like the colour-changing fibre only further confirm that we need to continue studying this field.
Image: Joseph Sandt
