Sharing thoughts on the Sheraton Park move

By Mika Laiho

Following the so-called ‘Town Hall’ meet organised by our Principal and GCR, with invited speakers from the University Executive Committee, my sentiments are a bit muddled. From what I gathered, many students are surprised to hear that Ustinov College is being relocated because of the closure of Durham University’s Stockton campus. Without any prior consultation due to ‘withholding sensitive information concerning planning,’ plans have been approved (but not yet finalised) to move Ustinov to the Sheraton Park area.

To summarise how I felt and to paraphrase Shakespeare: to move, or not to move, isn’t a question; it seems like an order: we are off to Sheraton Park, whether we like it or not!

But the real question for me is how graceful we are when we leave. Sure, we can kick up a stink and moan all we like, but I would have preferred to welcome undergraduate students with warm hearts, teary eyes and camaraderie as they begin to arrive. Given that I am only here for another year at the most, I would prefer setting a noble example for younger student peers. Goodwill may also act as an obvious reminder to the ‘establishment’ that we are a mature and valued postgraduate community, no matter where they move us.

Also, I try and see our imminent move from another’s perspective. For instance, we have all been undergraduate students once upon a time. It was once a tricky, sensitive period for most of us. Imagine being told that your college, which you soon became fondly attached to physically and emotionally, was closing down and you were being told that your future was uncertain.

Then imagine two possible scenarios. A huge, warm, endearing community of postgraduate students welcomed you with hugs and showered you with gifts, displaying photos of their best memories shared in your future home. The bar, the gym, the Café area, which your older peers had once loved as their own would be passed down to you. Would this not feel so bad? In fact, I think I would feel excited and privileged to move in!

Then contrast this with the triumphalist march of older postgraduate students, scary and angry about being ‘evicted’ from their college and home, sending furious complaints to the University Executive Committee because of an apparently scandalous idea to move you and your friends in and the ‘Ustinovians’ out. Oh, dear!

In a recent article in the North East’s Gazette titled ‘Durham University confirms plans to pull academic and college-based activities from Stockton,’ Professor Stuart Corbridge, Vice-Chancellor and Warden at Durham University, said: ‘We remain committed to both Stockton and Durham and are excited by these developments, following extensive consultation and discussion internally and more widely.’ Obviously, the ‘We’ in this statement didn’t include Ustinovians…

To me, the whole affair isn’t a pretty picture. But I abstained from voting for a ‘Referendum’ to remain at the Howlands site because I feel like the University Executive Committee have made their decision already. Moreover, the prettier picture of a small park, brand new facilities and a ‘fresh image’ for Ustinov College offers future Ustinovians a lot more at the expense of so much negotiation and hard work put in by these professionals.

My personal reflection is decidedly less centred on downsides and focusing on positives. Maybe this is more a reflection of my blasé attitude towards College life than a rounded, rational critique of injustice and lack of communication on behalf of those who planned to move us. But what do you think about the move? Let’s start discussions!

Photograph: Sarah Ross via flickr and creative commons