Sexism in Players: Durham’s newest nightclub’s unsavoury side

By Henry Jones

The most recent addition to Durham’s humble collection of nightclubs is the franchise Players, taking up Loveshack’s previous location in the Walkergate area. Having only been open for a little over a month, the bar has already drawn some negative attention.

On entering you quickly notice the staff uniforms — or specifically, the uniforms of the female bar staff. While male waiters are dressed in long-sleeved black shirts and trousers, the women don faux-cheerleading outfits that make Hooters Girls look conservative. The uniform is comprised of a tiny bralette top and a skirt so minuscule that one member of staff said, ‘some of the girls wear shorts underneath’; bending over leaves too little to the imagination.

The uniform also fails to provide pockets, leaving the women no option but to lodge their bottle openers into their bras. On ordering a beer then, one may be treated the experience of said opener being foisted from its bosomed location, opening your beverage, and being nestled home. What a treat for us and, I’m sure, the bar staff performing such a task.

One female clubgoer said she thought the uniform disparity was ‘verging on exploitative’

Speaking to a male bartender, he said that he found ‘the difference between the male and female uniforms weird’ and ‘outdated’. ‘Everyone that comes up [to the bar] will go for the girls’, and he suggested that the uniforms were clearly aimed at increasing sales.

One female source close to management (who does not work on the bar) said she found the female uniforms to be ‘perverse and problematic’. ‘It seems increasingly unfair that the men can be completely covered up yet the women are forced to wear skimpy outfits in ridiculous temperatures.’ She also stated that while ‘to some extent, it is their choice, this image and message is not welcomed by Durham students.’ One female clubgoer said she thought the uniform disparity was ‘verging on exploitative’, and her male friend said that he was ‘not a fan’ — it is ‘clearly just to get boys to buy drinks’.

While there is a market somewhere for scantily-clad waiting staff (although my opinion on that kind of bar would be an entirely different article), that place is certainly not Durham. However, even if Players marketed itself as offering the unique selling point of semi-nude staff, which it does not, why are the men not dressed in equally as revealing outfits?

Indeed, it is worth considering the government’s newest guidance on dress codes and sex discrimination. The advice, published in May, states that ‘Dress policies for men and women do not have to be identical. However, the standards imposed should be equivalent.’ Adding that, ‘any less favourable treatment because of sex’ could be deemed ‘unlawful’ on grounds of ‘direct discrimination’. ‘Dress codes [also] must not lead to harassment by colleagues or customers, so any requirements on women to dress in a provocative manner are likely to be unlawful on those grounds.’

Put simply, I see the bar as a sexist institution. This is 2018, the supposedly post-MeToo, post-equal-pay-transparency, post-rubbish-like-this era, and somehow Players can still operate an abhorrent uniform policy.

Put simply, I see the bar as a sexist institution.

Opinions seem to differ among the female staff: while one bar worker told me that ‘none of [the women] have a problem with it’, another said, ‘I was somewhat surprised […] that my male colleagues were given a long sleeved shirt … I can definitely say I would be more comfortable wearing less revealing clothing [but] it is a job at the end of the day.’

Similarly, one female employee told me, ‘I feel fine in the uniform and if I didn’t, I would ask to change’, but when I asked a different bartender if she had to wear the uniform she said, ‘Yes. It’s what all the Players bars do. When you sign up they say here’s your uniform.’

Another said she does not mind the uniform when ‘behind the bar’, but ‘outside it’s different … just because of the kind of men you get here on a Saturday … I often change before getting my cab home.’

Of course, people can choose to wear what they like, and it would be ridiculous to shame women for wearing any kind of clothing. But why should we tolerate a uniform that leaves staff feeling vulnerable?

As the government suggests, work uniforms should be provided on the most gender ‘equivalent’ terms possible, and the choice to bear the majority of your flesh should be a personal one, not the expected position of your employer. It is extremely distasteful to use the hypersexualisation of staff to boost your profits, and the situation is exacerbated when such a blatant gender imbalance is in play.

It is extremely distasteful to use the hypersexualisation of staff to boost your profits, and the situation is exacerbated when such a blatant gender imbalance is in play.

We must remember, as an 18 to 20-year-old in Durham, bar work is fairly unrewarding. Players pay a middling rate of £6.08, but on weekends that increases to £7.50, making it one of the highest-paid bars in Durham. Pairing that with the £1 bonus for each person that staff manage to sign up to events, along with other cash bonuses for sharing promotions on social media, it becomes fairly obvious that the club offers the most lucrative deal in Durham. It is perhaps unsurprising then that the majority of women working in the club expressed little issue with a uniform that provides them access to a greater income.

Daniel Ormonde, general manager of Players Bar Durham, told me he did ‘not have an opinion on the uniforms.’ He shrugged off suggestions of a sexist uniform policy and said that decisions like this are made by company directors, not general managers. ‘I just work for a company’, he added.

In addition to issues surrounding gender inequality, we should look at the effect of overt presentations of the female body. Uniforms like this not only perpetuate an objectifying view of women, but affect a discriminatory hiring policy: every female bartender I saw in Players when I visited was of a similar slim and large-breasted body type. A male member of staff pointed out that ‘you have a duty as a brand to promote body positivity’, and that ‘there doesn’t seem to be awareness of that [in Players].’ With 1.25 million people in the UK estimated to have an eating disorder, and student mental health at a crisis point, we desperately need those with public influence to act responsibly, starting with the promotion a variety of body types to more accurately represent the plethora of women in our society.

We desperately need those with public influence to act responsibly

In short, the uniforms in Players are a discriminatory and outdated presence in Durham, and it baffles me that such a policy can still be enacted. It is time that people woke up to everyday sexism and stopped ignoring such flagrant disregard for equality. Is that too much to ask?

Featured Image: Elliott Brown from Creative Commons via Flickr

Article image: Andrea Allen via Flickr