Separating parents in England and Wales: should fines be enforced if they refuse to mediate?
By Freya West
Since the introduction of no-fault divorce in 2021, there is an increasing willingness to remove the hostility usually attributed to family proceedings. Whether this was a correct decision is a debate in itself, but many have argued that this benefits any children that are involved, during the court proceedings and when their parents co-parent.
Recently, the government has gone further with this approach of protecting children during separation and family proceedings by announcing its plans to fine separating parents if they refuse mediation with each other. This will mean that separating parents must have at least made a sufficient attempt to agree upon their child custody and financial arrangements via mediation. This only applies to suitable low-level family court cases, so cases involving abuse or allegations of such are excluded from this new plan. Whilst a somewhat amicable separation via mediation seems favourable, it is questionable whether forcing it by threatening fines will help or cause damage.
For many individuals, attending a family court hearing can be a very nerve-wracking experience as many have never even stepped foot in a courtroom before. So, whilst the wig-wearing barrister frantically spits out their legal jargon that somehow relates to your personal life, you must wait there patiently before the judge reveals what they have decided; this time kindly translating it into simple terms from the lawyer code that they seemed to be talking in. Consequently, court is scary for adults, so you can only imagine how daunting it can be for children.
Mediation is cheaper than going to court, and many often feels as though their side of the story has been properly listened to
When a family dispute arises, mediation is often the first port of call to test whether the dispute can be resolved in a more informal and stress-free environment. The main aim of this is to make going through such a difficult time as easy as can be. Also, mediation is cheaper than going to court, and many often feel as though their side of the story has been properly listened to and considered, unlike during court hearings where the judge feels rushed to finish, so as not to disrupt the busy court schedule. Instead, mediation goes at the family’s pace, constantly keeping the end goal of a calm separation in sight. Furthermore, mediation allows the more serious cases that require court attention to be heard there, without too much of a backlog.
Alternatively, it could be argued that threatening a fine, if separating parents do not participate in mediation, is too harsh of a measure. This holds some weight, as problems could arise where there are uncooperative parents, as a joint effort to reach a mutually beneficial agreement is required, and mediation therefore becomes a waste of time and drags out the pain of separating for longer. However, the other option is to wait in the queue of the family courts, and then experience a more formal, emotional, and costly hearing, which ultimately seems more damaging. Also, mediation allows both parents to present themselves in a neutral light to their children, compared with the blame game often played in the courtroom.
As part of the government’s plan, it intends to provide an additional £15 million in funding, and extend the Family Mediation Voucher Scheme until April 2025, which provides families up to £500 to solve their disputes through mediation. Therefore, it would seem more beneficial for the government to carry out this funding and improve the mediation service, so that separating parents can see for themselves how much more attractive this is than going to court. As a consequence of this, it is likely that the popularity of mediation will automatically increase, without the threat of a fine. If the court backlog persists, the government could introduce a review system where lower-level family cases are automatically sent to mediation before being considered at the court level. This would allow mediation services to improve, therefore providing better solutions to families, and reinforce the last resort purpose of the courts.
It makes more sense for the government to consider extending its plans or encouragement of mediation after the system for families is fleshed-out and operating appropriately
Finally, some have questioned whether separating couples should be included in this. Whilst mediation may be beneficial here, it is important that children of separating parents are first protected from the trauma of familial separation. Therefore, it makes more sense for the government to consider extending its plans or encouragement of mediation after the system for families is fleshed-out and operating appropriately.
Overall, parental separation can be tough for many individuals, so the importance of attempting to maintain the family bond as best as possible is vital. Mediation seems like the way forward, but perhaps using a less harsh approach.
Image: Cottonbro Studios via Pexels
