Self-defence and responsibility: understanding American gun culture
By Ellie Joyce
On September 4th, tragedy hit Apalachee High School in Winder, Georgia when two students and two teachers lost their lives in the worst school shooting in the state’s history. As the U.S. approaches a critical political moment with the presidential election on the horizon, this event sparks questions about American gun culture and the concept of self-defence.
Fourteen-year-old Colt Gray was charged on September 6th with four counts of murder, alongside his father, Colin Gray, 54, who faces second–degree murder and involuntary manslaughter charges for providing a weapon to his son. The AR-15-style semi-automatic rifle was a Christmas gift from Colin Gray to his son. Concerns were raised when potential shooting threats were found on Discord, leading to police questioning last year. Despite this, Colin Gray stated that his son knew “the seriousness of weapons” and the case was closed with no grounds to confiscate the weapon.
Despite both Trump and Harris being gun owners, they represent different responses to the nationwide problem
The role of firearms in American life is deeply polarizing, reflected in divisions over the Second Amendment, which guarantees the right to bear arms. Approximately one-third of American adults identify as gun owners, reflecting how deeply embedded it is in society. Gun rights debates have divided the country for decades with themes of freedom and self-defence at the centre for those supporting their right to bear arms. For others, the Apalachee shooting brings to question Georgia’s gun laws. Unlike many states, Georgia lacks comprehensive background checks, sufficient gun storage laws and red-flag laws. This combined with a culture which normalizes weapons as gifts, has made obtaining a rifle relatively easy.

Image credit: Wikimedia Commons
In reference to the upcoming presidential election, gun violence will be crucial for voters on both sides of the debate. Despite both Trump and Harris being gun owners, they represent different responses to the nationwide problem making it a divisive topic within the election. Political analysts expect Harris to advocate for more thorough background checks on those purchasing weapons, particularly for those under 21, as well as reinstating the federal ban on assault weapons. The Bipartisan Safer Communities Act, signed by Biden in 2022, exemplifies Democrats’ previous efforts to tighten gun control, closing loopholes and supporting red-flag laws.
Conversely, Trump is predicted to resist new restrictions on gun ownership and will likely support the expansion of concealed–carry rights. Following the Georgia shooting, Trump faced backlash, especially from young voters, for hosting a debate watch party at a gun store near the site of the tragedy. Some may argue that Trump’s perceived indifference to such tragedies could alienate voters. As one young Democrat stated, “Donald Trump’s flagrant disregard for young Americans’ lives will cost him this election.”
74% of Republicans support arming teachers in schools, compared to only 27% of Democrats
pew research center
While some believe that the Apalachee school shooting could push voters towards Harris, who favours stricter gun laws, others argue that school shootings demonstrate the need for individuals to carry weapons for self-defence. Pew Research shows 74% of Republicans support arming teachers in schools, compared to only 27% of Democrats, highlighting the deep divide on the issue centred around self–defence.
The Apalachee school shooting demonstrates the broader crisis of gun violence in the U.S., where gun ownership and the need for self-defence are entrenched in the national psyche. As gun rights will be at the centre of the presidential race, this tragic event is likely to influence the debate to some degree but also deepen the divide between those advocating for restrictive gun laws and those defending the right to self-protection. With Georgia as a swing state, where gun culture runs deep, the outcome of this debate could be pivotal not just for the state, but for the entire election.
Feature image credit: Dick Clark via Flickr

