Science vs Arts: the great debate

Whether you study an arts or science degree, and where you study it, have huge implications for your future prospects new research suggests.

Students studying science degrees at research-led or 1994 group universities have a 31.7% chance of earning £30-50,000 compared to 16% of arts students.  Part of this group of universities is Durham University along with York and Bath. Russell Group universities include Oxford, Cambridge and Manchester.

The study subsequently found that in other universities the difference between science and arts students with the same earning potential was 12.7% and 8% respectively, thus much lower than their counterparts.

Representatives from the “newer” universities however, were not completely happy with the study’s findings.  Deian Hopkin, vice-chancellor of London South Bank University said: “What is important is whether the researchers looked at the economic, gender and racial profile of universities.

“I think you will find that the research-intensive universities have the least diverse student body, and they score least well for widening participation. They are also less racially mixed and have the lowest proportion of part-time students.”

Nevertheless the figures seem to speak for themselves as the trend is completely evident across all undergraduate degree subjects. Apart from education, therefore the university you attend can play as big a role as the type of degree you study.

Rather than being new or revolutionary the study used previous data that included limited student surveys and logs of where students actually ended up after graduation.

For “newer” universities which include former polytechnics and those not within the two groups, it was also suggested that there should be more emphasis on offering specific things students wanted to study within their degrees.

In contrast 1994 and Russell group universities placed more emphasis on the reputation of their institution as well as the course and its employment prospects.

The president of the National Union of Students, Wes Streeting, said: “It is very pleasing to note the striking similarity in employment rates for graduates from all types of institution, three and a half years after leaving university.

It is no surprise that graduates from research-intensive institutions go on to earn more on average. However, we need to remember that these returns are far from guaranteed, so these figures cannot be used to back up the argument for institutions to set their own fees.”

It is evident that certain courses can yield different results. When choosing to study an arts or a science degree the student’s personal profile, achievements, attributes and work experience often play equally productive roles regarding employment opportunities.

It would be naïve to assume that students go into the university application process completely unaware of the weight certain subjects may have, when pursuing  subject-specific vocations.

The study and subsequent debate has also been accompanied by a report from a Right wing think-tank. It suggests that students are “spoon fed” and prefer the “X Factor to A grades”.  The report concurs that recent falling standards in schools as well as a testing culture has meant that many students “lack the attitude and skills needed for the workplace.”    As a result “personal responsibility” has been removed from the system.  The report focuses on school students rather than university graduates questioning the relevance of the report’s findings for current students.

The research itself was limited only to a certain number of graduates and did not find too much out about the exact differences between universities in each of these “elite” groups and that of each individual course.

Whether a science degree is worth more than an arts degree from the same institution is obviously the debate that arises from the headline research.

Many past students from both backgrounds will have huge differences themselves in what they earn and as it has been noted simply placing the content of your degree above anything else can be misleading.

It is rumoured that Microsoft and the Conservative party are working to devise a system which profiles the earning potential of students from each university.  Maybe Bill Gates and David Cameron will have the answer…