Scandalous Swimwear
By: Kate McIntosh
In 1907, on a Boston beach, a woman wore a dark one-piece bathing suit that covered her knees and shoulders. She was promptly arrested – for incident exposure. Annette Kellerman’s streamlined suit clung to her waist and legs and in it she had broken a swathe of swimming world records early in her career. Kellerman was toeing the line between criminalisation and ascendency to iconic status; and the alleged arrest was so much a scandal that her name became a byword for mystique.
An uproar on a far larger scale was the reaction to those widely shared images of French police forcing a Muslim women to strip on a beach in Nice. Several French towns banned the Burkini this summer, an innovation which makes it possible for women who wear full or partial body coverings to swim in public. The localised bans were later trampled by a high court decision, but the controversy persists. At the intersection of fashion and ideology, little has done more to exemplify the clash between female autonomy and political circumstance than scandalous swimwear.
Eighteenth century swimmers wore long shapeless tunics in the water, until what was then known as ‘Turkish dress’ kicked up some controversy mid century. Fanny Kemble, a British anti-slavery campaigner, first wore the light tunic over flannel pantaloons, inspired by the traditional dress of Muslim women. The flexibility and freedom this afforded women was outrageous in the context of Victorian bone corsets, hoop skirts and bonnets; all of which were intended to constrain and conceal women.
In this new ‘Turkish’ swimwear women had much more freedom, so much so that the suit provoked controversy because it encroached on male territory. Utility in women’s fashion was a source of scandal, because it allowed them to get on and do what they liked. And in the case of swimwear, notions of utility clashed with the era’s highly held values of ‘modesty’ and ‘passivity’. This was still the case when at her trial Annette Kellerman exclaimed ‘I can’t swim wearing more stuff than you can hang on a clothesline’. The judge ruled that in future she must wear a cape to the water’s edge to conserve her modesty.
Fanny Durack’s skin tight suit helped liberalise trends when she won the first ever women’s Olympic medal and broke the 100m record in the pool in 1912, but ultimately swimwear fashion remained largely dependent on what the world thought about women’s bodies.
The next big shift is swimwear convention came mid-20th century. In its infancy the two-piece swimsuit was the product of post-war fabric shortages, but the man who christened it the ‘bikini’ saw its explosive potential. Named after Bikini Atoll, a nuclear test site, Louis Réard’s creation was initially spurned by fashion’s greats. So widespread was the distaste that Réard had to hire a Parisian exotic dancer – Micheline Bernardini – to model it, because everyone else refused. Star swimmer Annette Kellerman, the woman who triggered a swimwear revolution, publicly condemned the bikini as a ‘mistake’. ‘The bikini shows too much. It shows a line that makes the leg look ugly, even with the best of figures.’ she explained.
A decade passed before the infamous two-piece reappeared in the mainstream. Réard spoke of it like an atom bomb; ‘small but devastating’. Brigitte Bardot was one of the handful of screen stars who helped popularise the scandalous suit in the USA. The fifties’ post-rationing frivolity fuelled the rise of the bikini, and for some it symbolised social degeneration which accompanied teen culture. The magazine Modern Girl proclaimed that ‘it is inconceivable that any girl with tact and decency would ever wear such a thing’. Scores of towns banned the bikini, and the Vatican went as far as to call it ‘sinful’. Inevitably, in an era of sexual revolution the bikini became enormously popular among a new generation of girls.

Yet this kind of controversy is not at all a thing of the past. When just weeks ago a woman in a tunic, leggings and a headscarf, asleep on French beach was surrounded by police and abused by members of the public, the long running debate was reignited. Presidential hopeful Nicholas Sarkozy has already said he’ll repeal the high court decision quashing the Burkini ban if elected next year. Prime Minister Manual Valls quickly joined him and said full body swimwear represented ‘the enslavement of women’. Sixty years ago the bikini was the epitome of scandal and poor morals, but today it has come to symbolize French liberté. Assumedly in some circles the bikini is now the only option for any authentically French woman. If a Muslim woman chooses not to comply, her right to citizenship is revoked.
The deeply misogynistic tendency to view women’s skin as either symbolic of evil or embodying liberation ultimately manifests in what we think about swimwear. We’ve arrived at a point in history where the clothes women wear are either deemed acceptable or dangerous depending on who they are. Women’s bodies have long been legitimate territory for ideological wars, and swimwear will only be scandalous for as long as it has the potential to threaten how we deal with that reality.

Photo credit: Wikimedia Commons, Flickr user Tom Simpson, Flickr user Landahlauts
