Sandy: The Most Important Voter?

by Alistair Symes

With no subway, no stock exchange, no annual marathon, the city of New York has been unrecognisable in the wake of Storm Sandy. Last week in many communities along the US East Coast, everything was put on hold for the relief effort. The timing of the storm seems to have been at the worst time for a country at the height of election campaigning. But for both Barack Obama and Mitt Romney the storm has been used for political advantage in such a close race to the White House.

A key aspect of being President is the need to react to events as they occur, and both presidential campaigns have been forced to react sensitively to this natural disaster. For Obama, the task was much easier because as President he could direct the relief effort. Being seen as leader of the people in their hour of need is much more valuable than any political rally for the election.

Pictures of Obama shaking hands with rescue workers and residents in Atlantic City, New Jersey, provided the Democratic campaign with evidence that Obama was able to connect with the American people in hard times. Obama has been praised for his cutting of red tape to remove bureaucracy hindering the relief effort.

For the Romney campaign it was important that he was also seen to be doing something for the people affected, however the scope of his actions was much more limited. Romney tried to turn an election rally into a ‘storm relief’ event, calling upon the people of Montgomery, Ohio to bring what non-perishable foods they could for those affected in New Jersey.

But this event seemed to be a strange mix of a republican rally and a relief effort, with both a biographical Romney video and tables filled with canned food. Romney recounted a rather unconvincing story of when he had to pick up litter from a high school football pitch, relating this to the cleanup operation after Storm Sandy. The destruction in Eastern America is much greater than a football pitch, and the lives, houses and businesses lost are a much greater problem than high school litter.

Given the limits of his power, Romney needed to be seen working with the community and in the suspension of official campaigning, relief events seemed to be the only way. A man often criticised for his inability to connect with all of the people of America perhaps also saw a chance to be seen as the man of the community.

Even members of Romney’s Republican Party have praised Obama for his quick response to the disaster. The New Jersey Governor, Chris Christie, usually a fierce critic of the Obama administration, praised the president for his “extraordinary leadership” through his “personal concern and compassion for the people of our state.”  The independent New York Mayor, Michael Bloomberg, has just endorsed Obama for the presidency, citing his views on climate change as fundamental to his vote in the aftermath of the destruction in New York.

It seems that Obama is benefitting from being the man in office, which gives him far greater scope for action than Romney. After the first presidential debate, a defensive, subdued Obama faced a tougher challenge as the incumbent, as he had to justify his administration in the face of criticism from Romney who has no presidential record to defend. But Storm Sandy has shown that in times of disasters outside of the government’s control, it is much easier be the incumbent president than an outside campaigner.

Bloomberg’s endorsement of Obama also raises the importance of climate change in the election, which for many Americans is now a present issue, rather than a distant problem for the future. Suddenly both candidates’ policies on climate change have been more heavily scrutinised, and the Democrats have been quick to criticise Romney on his failure to engage with the issue. Romney’s attack on Obama in the first debate for wasting too much money on wind and solar energy now seems to have backfired. Bill Clinton in a rally in Minnesota on Wednesday condemned Romney for ridiculing Obama for his “efforts to fight global warming.” It seems an issue which has not been given priority by both candidates is suddenly becoming more prominent in the final days up to the election.

It is difficult to gauge how much of an effect Storm Sandy will have on the outcome of the election, but in such a close race, it could provide the difference, and it seems the incumbent president is best placed to take advantage of it politically.

Photograph: Flickr ID: SmileyReilly