Saints or Sinners: Spygate Volume II
By Blair Galloway
The 40th anniversary of the Championship play-offs this year saw Hull City promoted to the Premier League. Yet the spectacle of the ‘richest game in football’ was upstaged by Southampton’s covert theatrics at Middlesborough’s training ground.
News of a Southampton analyst spying on Boro’s pre-match training session became the biggest story in English football media overnight, eventually culminating in the Saints being expelled from the tournament altogether ten days later. Following the fallout of the EFL’s ruling, there appears much more to this story than it originally seemed.
On the 1st of June the League Arbitration Panel released the full written reasons as to why Tonda Eckert’s team decided to spy on their opposition not once, but at least on three occasions. The primary offence against Boro has been tied to the speculation over the fitness of Championship Player of the Year Hayden Hackney, in what turned out to be a completely unnecessary investigation since the midfielder played neither leg of the semi-final. Meanwhile, similar offences against Ipswich Town and Oxford United further point to a club culture in which sporting integrity has fallen to the wayside.
In fact, reports reveal how some members of the coaching staff viewed this spying as a joking matter, a sentiment not shared by the junior interns who were pressurised into doing the manager’s dirty work. WhatsApp messages between colleagues at the club highlight how the interns felt powerless in the matter, but still repeatedly expressed their displeasure towards their orders. As a result, the Arbitration Panel concluded that these three incidents resemble a “contrived and determined plan from the top down” that was intended to gain a competitive advantage.
The primary offence against Boro has been tied to the speculation over the fitness of Championship Player of the Year Hayden Hackney
The greatest irony of the whole fiasco is that the Saints were winless against each of the three sides they had spied on beforehand. The ineffectiveness of such escapades, however, cannot detract from the underhand intentions of the club. A message sent to the analyst who spied on Oxford that read “You legend. Manager loved it”, evidently shows how Eckhert’s coaching staff saw value in their “extracurricular” preparations, regardless of EFL regulations.
Responding to their expulsion from the play-offs, accompanied by a four-point deduction for their next season in the Championship, the club hierarchy continue to stress the disproportionate nature of the punishment. An official club statement argues that given the potential financial losses of £200 million, that come with promotion to the Premier League, their expulsion constitutes the “the largest penalty ever imposed on an English football club”.
Moreover, comparisons to the sanctions faced by Leeds United after the original Spygate case in 2019, which only amounted to a £200,000 fine, once again indicate Southampton’s lack of accountability. With regards to Leeds, there was no explicit rule to prohibit watching the training sessions of upcoming opponents. Consequently, the introduction of EFL Regulation 127 banned teams from repeating Leeds’ misbehaviour, placing a 72-hour deadline before kick-off whereby spying is strictly forbode. Without direct precedent, the EFL have decided to make an example out of the Saints, which judging by their tone-deaf response is looking more and more deserved.
This cautionary tale for other English football teams has sparked conversations around the broader status of spying in professional sport. Sticking to football, the practice is more normalised, and even praised, across the continent. Providing context to his actions, Eckert commented that spying was commonplace throughout his coaching education in Germany and Italy, citing Pep Guardiola’s experience from managing Bayern Munich. However, the German’s ignorance to the taboo status of spying in English football is no excuse, especially since he already had spent 15 months as assistant manager at Barnsley in the 20/21 season.
Another recent case of spying in sport was seen at the 2024 Paris Olympics, as Canada were caught flying a drone over New Zealand’s women’s football team. Head coach Bev Priestman, and two other members of staff, were banned by FIFA from any footballing activity for 12 months, a fate that potentially awaits Eckert in the near future. Furthermore, former incidents of espionage in F1 and the NFL outline a similar pattern. In 2007 both Mclaren and the New England Patriots were punished for their respective exploits, including a $100 Million fine for the British manufacturer and the forfeiture of the American franchise’s 2008 1st round draft pick. In all cases, the risk attached to spying has outweighed any potential reward.
EFL Regulation 127 banned teams from repeating Leeds’ misbehaviour, placing a 72-hour deadline before kick-off whereby spying is strictly forbode
Nevertheless, it is ultimately the fans who are caught in the crossfire of their team’s malpractice, emerging as the biggest victims of these operations. Returning to the Spygate saga, supporters of Middlesborough and Hull are rightfully aggrieved at the undue anxiety caused by Southampton’s stupidity. Meanwhile for Saints fans themselves, myself included, the reality that a 20-game unbeaten league run was all for nothing is certainly a tough pill to swallow. The club’s affiliation with cheating will stick for generations to come. Surely now, other clubs will dare not follow suit.
Image by Jordan Coleman via Pexels

