Saint or Sinner? The truth behind Jannik Sinner’s controversial US Open victory

By George Murray

Jannik Sinner swept through the field to claim his second grand slam title at the US Open earlier this September, but what should have been the story of a man cementing himself as by far the best player in the world was instead overshadowed by the announcement he had tested positive for anabolic steroids in April 2024. 

While the International Tennis Integrity Agency (ITIA) had cleared him of all wrongdoing and, in the curt words of Sinner’s statement, “the matter is now closed”, the fact that one of tennis’ biggest stars could potentially have been doping was all anyone could talk about throughout his US Open run. 

Doping is a contentious topic, in part because of how tricky it is to understand without being an expert in the field. Sinner’s statement said he tested positive for “less than a billionth of a gram” of clostebol, an anabolic steroid with performance enhancing capabilities, that entered his system through his physiotherapist who used a product containing clostebol to treat a cut on his own finger. 

As far as Sinner and his lawyers are concerned, his physiotherapist Giacomo Naldi, accidentally introduced the drug through a skin lesion whilst giving Sinner a treatment with his bare hands. Is this a credible story? The ITIA certainly thought so, since they cleared Sinner of all wrongdoing as did the three independent experts who assisted the tribunal – they agreed not only that the Italian’s explanation was plausible but that the amount of clostebol was so small that it would not have had any performance enhancing effects. 

They agreed not only that the Italian’s explanation was plausible but that the amount of clostebol was so small that it would not have had any performance enhancing effects

This exoneration provided by the ITIA has not stemmed the flow of criticism, however, with some even going so far as to say they don’t believe Sinner’s version of events: the ever-vocal Nick Kyrgios posted on X “ridiculous – whether it was accidental or planned. You get tested twice with a banned (steroid) substance… you should be gone for 2 years. Your performance was enhanced. Massage cream…. Yeah nice” and then in response to a comment: “accidental? You truly believe that the physio rubbed physio cream onto a cut that made him fail 2 anabolic steroid tests. Cmon potato.”

Kyrgios does raise an interesting point: the fact that the entire investigation was covered up and not revealed to the public until its completion. In past instances of doping, players have been suspended for months, even years as they waited for a final ITIA decision. The speed and secrecy with which Sinner, one of tennis’ greatest assets at present, was dealt with has led many to question the impartiality and fairness of tennis’ governing bodies. 

“This is not right” wrote British player Liam Broady. “Plenty of players go through the same thing and have to wait months or YEARS for their innocence to be declared. Not a good look.” 

Even Novak Djokovic weighed in on the issue: “I can understand the sentiments of a lot of players that are questioning whether they are treated the same … hopefully the governing bodies of our sport will be able to learn from this case and have a better approach for the future. I think collectively there has to be a change.”

“I think collectively there has to be a change”

Novak Djokovic

Djokovic is of course right that each player should be treated the same when it comes to doping and given the way Sinner’s case was so quickly disposed of, it is understandable many might think the International Tennis Federation and ITIA have done away with the case so one of their stars does not become embroiled in a lengthy doping scandal.

Despite this, the matter is, as Sinner says, now closed. As far as the governing bodies and medical experts are concerned, the Italian did not dope and as such we as tennis fans must assume that as well. After all, none of us are more qualified to pass judgement than the independent specialists who aided the tribunal and as such we too should consider Sinner’s innocence unimpeachable unless further evidence comes to light. 

The positive drug tests should most definitely not overshadow his US Open victory either, since to do it in such a dominant fashion with the speculation and player backlash on his mind is arguably more impressive than it would have been without it. 

However, there is most definitely a wider discussion over procedure that needs to be had: players must be treated equally, regardless of their ranking and star power, and it is this that must be the main takeaway from the scandal. It is naturally not a good look for tennis itself, a sport that has famously been plagued with high-profile doping cases throughout its history, so the quick closure of issues like this is, on the whole, a good thing; the sport’s governing bodies must simply make sure everyone is afforded that same luxury.

Image: Kena Betancur via Wikimedia Commons