Russia has expanded. Will NATO?

By Tom Mulholland

As President Putin committed to “victory in Ukraine” at a Kremlin-organized concert in Moscow’s Red Square this week, across the border President Zelensky committed Ukraine to a fast-track application to NATO. The Red Square concert was held in celebration of the Russian annexation of four eastern Ukrainian territories – Donetsk, Kherson, Luhansk and Zaporizhzhia. The move follows several sham referendums in these regions on the question of joining the Russian Federation. Any hope of these referendums being free and fair have been dismissed, with video evidence showing the Russian military intimidating voters. These referendums have, from the Russian perspective, vindicated the annexation of these four regions of Ukraine and their expansion of the Russian Federation. The referendums have been used to justify Putin’s “special military operation” and legitimise the increasing Russian mobilisation of conscripts as the conflict continues into the winter. As a result of these sham referendums supporting the Russian annexation, Putin can now claim that Ukraine are the aggressors within Russian territory and are threatening Russian people.

Predictably, this “enlargement of Russia” is unrecognized by the West and by international institutions such as the United Nations. There has been widespread condemnation of Russia’s actions by Western leaders, laying the groundwork for further action. Zelensky’s message remains simple: the chest-beating of the unfriendly Bear next door change nothing. Ukraine remains determined to end the war with the same sovereign territories it entered with. So why has Ukraine applied for fast-track membership of the US-led security alliance that is NATO when their strategy is to ‘keep calm and carry on’? Well, if Ukraine’s entry to NATO is unanimously ratified by all 30 member states, it would be able to invoke Article 5, which states that an attack on one member state is considered an attack on all. Put simply, the armies of North America and most of Europe would have to engage Russia on the battlefields of Ukraine. This would be an enormous escalation from the West’s current involvement in the war, which consists mainly of economic sanctions on Russia and providing arms and training for the Ukrainian military.

Zelensky’s message remains simple: the chest-beating of the unfriendly Bear next door changes nothing.

For this course of action to occur seems extremely unlikely. Domestically, NATO members states would have to justify fighting a war that has already inflated a global energy crisis, and a war that Ukraine has already had major success in alone as the result of huge economic and military assistance Western states have provided. Let us not forget, that over 200 days into a war that Russia claimed would take 3 days, they have failed to achieve any of their main objectives. Even so, the fact that any application for membership of NATO must receive unanimous support for its member states means that the odds are stacked against Ukraine. Something has got to give if Ukraine is going to get universal ratification of its membership application mid-war. NATO could revise its treaty and remove Article 5’s commitment to immediate mutual defence of any member state; or Western states could reconsider and see the risk of escalation with Russia as a risk worth taking, and accept Ukraine’s membership. Both options are considered highly unlikely as they pose too much risk for NATO’s current member states.

The UK Ministry of Defence published an intelligence update on 29th September, stating that the exodus of people fleeing Russia to escape ‘partial mobilisation’ into its army are mostly the well-educated middle class, which has the potential to create a huge brain drain and continue to weaken a crippling economy. Russia seems to be its own worst enemy, with its own citizens either being slaughtered or fleeing the country. Maybe NATO believes Ukraine does not need membership to win this war. Regardless, it seems unlikely that Ukraine will gain membership whilst at war with Russia. Ukraine may have to wait until its membership is seen as a deterrence for future conflict; rather than an escalation of a current one. Consequently, it sounds like the West may continue to observe from the side chanting “Slava Ukraini”, while not giving Russia any opportunity to use NATO’s assistance to justify further escalation.

Image: Kidfly182 via Wikimedia Commons