Rotation, rotation, rotation: has the FA Cup lost its magic?

By Callum Morley

It’s that time of year again. Over the past fortnight, football fans have been subject to the annual BBC fanfare telegraphing the return of the FA Cup and all of its ‘magic’, matched, increasingly, by the voice of sceptics who lament that the competition is simply not what it once was.

For a tournament celebrating its 158th birthday there is, understandably, a great deal of nostalgia surrounding the FA Cup. Over the course of its long history, the cup has yielded a remarkable range of extraordinary giant-killings, unique moments and lasting memories for the entirety of the football community. It is a tournament truly like no other and one which, ultimately, means something different to everyone.

Yet, so the critics say, the world’s oldest national cup competition has lost its way in recent years. Having been the ultimate prize in English Football for so long, recent seasons have seen this historical tournament regarded with equal value to the relatively trivial and sentimentally shallow Carabao Cup. Much of this negative trajectory is attributed to England’s major footballing clubs using the competition as an opportunity for rotation. Herein lies the main issue of the cup’s subjectivity. For as much as the cup can (and indeed does) mean so much to some people, to elite clubs and managers it has recently appeared to mean very little.

As such, those who defy the cup’s continued magic in 2021 create passionate comparisons and binaries. Compared to the competition’s heyday, when Wimbledon’s ‘Crazy Gang’ beat Liverpool in a historic final or when footballing minnows Hereford United eliminated First Division Newcastle, modern upsets against second string XIs simply don’t carry the same sentimental weight.

Money talks, and it has a much louder voice than the faint cries of the FA Cup’s sentimental value in the modern climate

The decline of the competition theoretically began with the turn of the millennium, when Ferguson’s Manchester United prioritised their Club World Cup tie and fielded a sub-par team for their FA cup fixture. For proponents of this view, therefore, it is only when England’s ‘Big Six’ start to demonstrably ‘care’ about the cup once again that the competition will become the high prize it once was. Indeed, much effort has been made to get those at the top of England’s footballing pyramid back on side. Discussions about rewarding victors with Champions League spaces, greater prize funds and even adding Scottish teams to the mix have been fielded for some time, though change has proved elusive.

There is, admittedly, a reality that fans wishing for the FA Cup to return to its 1970s prestige increasingly face. In English football, the Premier League and the Champions League are unequivocally dominant. Modern football is a financial business and it is within these competitions that the best sponsorship, TV viewership and promotional opportunities exist. It is unrealistic to believe that West Bromwich Albion’s Sam Allardyce, desperate to protect his immaculate relegation record, is going to risk the fitness of his players and subsequent hopes of survival on a third-round tie with Blackpool. While West Brom fans would dream of a cup run as much as their rivals, it is, ultimately, the shareholders and club owners’ interests which are prioritised in the modern game. Money talks, and it has a much louder voice than the faint cries of the FA Cup’s sentimental value in the modern climate.

The world, quite simply, has changed since the competition’s supposed ‘golden days’ and, as such, appeals to ‘make the FA Cup great again’ are searching for something that is unlikely to come back.

That is not to say, however, that there is no ‘magic’ in the FA Cup of today.

For a competition that has been in decline since the millennium, it is a mystery that a football fan such as myself, born in 2000, has been able to fall in love with the competition in the same manner as previous generations. As a lifelong fan and four-year season ticket holder at Yeovil Town (a team with their own substantial giant-killing history), I have witnessed my fair share of FA cup ties. The stand-out moments are, undoubtedly, Manchester United’s visits to Huish Park in 2015 and 2018 where Angel Di Maria, Alexis Sanchez and Marcus Rashford shared the pitch with players regularly found in the local Asda on weekends.

From the moment the draw was confirmed, it was all anyone spoke of for days and, as the conversations grew in number, so did those murmurs of hope. They couldn’t, could they? Not little old Yeovil Town? The FA Cup alone brought the community together and as the queues at Huish Park’s ticket gates grew and grew, one would have been hard pushed to find a fan who felt that the competition’s magic had died.

It is, of course, easy to see such passion for these hallmark, one-in-a-million fixtures. Having experienced a number of ‘lesser’ ties against opposition from the same tier, however, that magic has never felt absent. Any victory comes with the knowledge that the team is ‘in the hat’ and provides that hope of progressing one stage further or taking on one of the footballing elite. So much of the cup’s magic can be found in these smaller individual moments. Tell a Wigan or Bradford fan, moreover, with such recent and famous successes that the competition is dying and doesn’t produce the emphatic moments which it used to. 

Indeed, the standout fixture of the most recent round of ties where the FA Cup’s continued charm and unique character was on full display took place at Rossett Park, as eighth-tier Marine AFC took on José Mourinho’s Tottenham Hotspur.

There is something universal in the appeal of seeing a part-time binman take on superstars like Harry Kane, with all but the Spurs faithful hoping that the former might even expose, outplay and, in all likelihood, clatter the England captain. Perhaps within every FA Cup tie such as this, those ‘lesser’ players are representing the majority of the football fans: never good enough to make it professionally but who would fancy themselves on their day. As long as there is the possibility of such match-ups, so different to the average weekend fixture, it is hard to see the cup’s magic truly disappearing any time soon.

As much as these David and Goliath fixtures hold an appeal in their own right, there is magic beyond the names on the team sheet. In what other competition would you see over 30,000 fans purchase ‘virtual’ tickets in order to give Marine AFC a much-needed financial boost? It is only in games such as this that you find a Marine fan tweeting a picture of Gareth Bale, scorer of perhaps the greatest ever Champions League final goal, from a tree in his back garden. It is only due to Mourinho’s rotation that 16-year-old Alfie Devine was able to score on his first ever senior footballing appearance.

There is something in the universal appeal of seeing a part-time binman take on superstars like Harry Kane

Money, commerciality and rotation. Not only is the FA Cup still capable of producing the emotion and elation from fans, its magic can come from precisely those modern features which supposedly ruin the competition.

The attempts of older generations and BBC executives to resurrect the FA Cup to its former glory are understandable. It is a competition of immense emotional value and English football really would not be the same without it. Trying to form a direct replica of 1970s football in 2021, however, is unrealistic. Through largescale financial investment, packed footballing schedules and rapid cultural transformation, too much has changed for this to be possible.

One truth, however, remains constant. The magic of the cup is in its subjectivity. There is no one standard of quality, tradition or greatness to be met. In providing completely unique experiences and memories for football fans year on year, the uniqueness of the FA cup exists today as much as it has ever done. Magic, moreover, is to be found in the minutiae of modernity.

While the nature of the FA Cup has been required to change, and will continue to do so, there is, as ever, a reason to ‘Get Up for the Cup’.

Image: Steve Daniels via Creative Commons

https://www.dunelm.org.uk/donations/palatinate