Rodrigo Duterte’s response to coronavirus as a populist leader
By Will Marshall
The Coronavirus pandemic has proven to be the greatest test of skill in which most national leaders will ever face in their political careers. A disease which does not respect borders, this fails to explain the great disparity in which countries have faced in their levels of success in handling the pandemic. Taking a look at top five countries with the unenviable positions of having the most confirmed Coronavirus cases, a clear trend is evident: four (USA, Brazil Russia and the UK) are currently led by populist leaders. Across the globe, even when data is adjusted per capita, populist-led countries have appeared to have fared considerably worse in the pandemic than their neighbours. One country however appears to have bucked the trend. Under the leadership of Rodrigo Duterte’s populist PDP-Laban party, the Philippines, with a population of over 100 million people has recorded less than a thousand deaths. But what exactly sets Duterte apart from his populist counterparts?
Areas of the Philippines have seen what has widely been considered as one of the strictest lockdowns in any democratic nation. In Metro Manila, the epicentre of the country’s outbreak, significant restrictions have been imposed on all aspects of life with citizens ordered to stay at home with only limited exemptions for a small number of essential workers, as well as strictly controlled visits to supermarkets and pharmacies. Duterte himself even controversially commented that anybody who violated lockdown measures risked being shot dead.
The strictness of the regional lockdowns imposed by Duterte is perhaps what sets him most apart from other populist leaders. Whilst figures such as Trump and Bolsonaro largely hesitated in introducing strict and coherent lockdowns, Duterte acted swiftly, introducing quarantine in Manilla in mid-March when the whole country had seen just fourteen deaths. Even now, whilst other populist countries such as Russia continue to ease lockdown measures to levels of near normality despite increasing case numbers, areas of the Philippines still remain in extremely stringent lockdown, with only a minor easing in mid-May after almost two months of near house arrest.
As of June 2, just three of the Phillipines’ seventeen regions have recorded over 1000 cases.
Duterte’s attempt to control the spread of the disease has admittedly been heavily assisted by the country’s natural geography, however. An archipelago nation, the difficulty in travelling between different islands of the country, particularly after the imposing of local lockdowns in highly affected areas, has meant the disease has largely been concentrated in a small number of areas, a benefit not afforded to mostly contiguous nations such as America, where the interconnected of states has allowed the disease to spread much faster. As of June 2nd, just three of the Phillipines’ seventeen regions have recorded over 1000 cases.
Duterte’s relative success in keeping Coronavirus deaths low in comparison to other populist nations has however ultimately come at a significant cost. With parts of the Philippines having now been in lockdown for longer than any other part of the world, the restrictions on day to day life has sparked questions over whether some civil liberties will ever return. In the midst of the pandemic, the nation’s biggest broadcaster, ABS-CBN, was forced off the air by the government in what was considered a further attack on the countries already limited levels of press freedom. Whilst most populists have been characterised by their failure to act decisively in this pandemic, Duterte has proven himself to have done the opposite. His decision to lock down swiftly and strongly has undoubtably saved lives and set him apart from most other populist leaders, but it must be questioned whether his response is purely a demonstration of his competence as a leader, or a thinly veiled excuse to gain more power.
Image: Ben Bin via Unsplash
