Rise of the far right & a solution in Catalonia?
Robert Birch
The Spanish general election of the 10th November, the fourth election held in the country in the past three years, once again returned an inconclusive verdict on the future of the country. Whilst, once again, there was no clear majority in favour of any party, a coalition of left-wing parties including the social-democratic Socialist Party and the populist, far left party Podemos appear to be moving towards being able to form a somewhat stable government. This article will illustrate a few of the main trends that can be seen from these results and ask what precisely this means for the future of Spain, especially given the ongoing political unrest in the region of Catalonia.
Much of the support for Vox appears to be coming from a disillusionment with mainstream parties
A few notable trends can be found in the election results, with the most obvious talking point being the rise of the far-right populist party Vox and the almost complete collapse of the centre-right Citizens party. Vox itself is a socially-conservative, anti-immigrant (and especially anti-Islamic) party who draws upon a large part of its support from ‘left-behind’ voters, winning the most votes in two old industrial regions – around Madrid and in the south of Spain, especially around Murcia. The importance of this result is clear: Vox is the first overtly far-right party that has been able to hold seats in the Spanish Congress since 1982, and the common perception that Spain was immune to the right-wing populism popular in many European countries has been proven to be untrue. Much of the support for Vox appears to be coming from a disillusionment with mainstream parties, with Citizens losing over 50 seats from the previous elections in April. It remains to be seen whether support for Vox is more to do with protesting the status quo or a genuine show of support for the policies it holds, which seek to transport Spain back towards its more authoritarian, dictatorial past.

Perhaps the most important issue of these elections has been the developing unrest in Catalonia, with right-wing parties seeking to undermine the left through accusations of being ‘soft’ on protesters. Pablo Casado, the leader of the traditional right-wing party of Spain, the People’s Party, called Pedro Sánchez, leader of the Socialist Party and the acting Prime Minister, the ‘biggest villain in Spain’s democratic history’ for holding talks with Quim Torrà, the president of the Catalonian regional parliament. Although, as with any election, the result was a culmination of many factors, what is happening in Catalonia, a region rocked by major protests since independence leaders were sentenced to long jail terms over a referendum and unilateral independence declaration in 2017, has been an important aspect.
To sum up extremely generally, parties on the left in Spain tend to see the Spanish state as plurinational and are accepting of the possibility of holding multiple national identities within the wider umbrella of Spain, whilst the right seeks to create, maintain, or impose (depending on your viewpoint) a unified feeling of ‘Spanishness’ amongst the entire population. Therefore, whilst parties on the left have expressed a willingness to at least engage in talks with figures from the independence movements in Catalonia, the majority of figures on the right have made it clear that they would certainly not engage in any way that would give legitimacy to a movement they see as illegal and against the Spanish constitution, which states that Spain is one country and is indivisible.
It is likely that at least an increased level of federalism will be high on the agenda for the new government
This is where the importance of the PSOE/Podemos coalition comes into play: unlike if the right had been able to form a government, it is highly likely that a left-wing government would be able to engage in negotiations with the Catalan parliament and try to diffuse tensions. It is extremely unlikely that, for example, a government containing ministers from Vox, who are in favour of the suspension of autonomy in Catalonia, would do anything to try to diffuse the situation, and would probably end up inflaming the situation even further. Whilst these negotiations would probably not end up with anything that would lead to independence in the short-run (for example, a clear in-out referendum – Sánchez has made it clear he does not want another referendum in Catalonia) due to the electoral pressure this would put on the Socialist Party from its competitors on the right, it nevertheless could put in place building-blocks towards some sort of future settlement, for example a gradual transition of power away from Madrid towards the regions. The coalition would have to rely on various other regional parties, for example the left-wing Catalan nationalist ERC, which has voted in favour of supporting the Sánchez coalition in return for negotiations between separatists and the government, or the Basque nationalist PNV. It is therefore likely that at least an increased level of federalism will be high on the agenda for the new government.
Therefore, whilst the most obvious result of the elections of 10N in Spain is the rise of a hitherto dormant far right, it nevertheless contains a few more interesting results upon closer analysis. It seems like, for the first time since 2017, a resolution to the problems in Catalonia could be on the verge of being found. Whether anything actually does happen is another question: politics is always hard to predict, and it remains to be seen what the new government will actually do.
Image: via Fshoq blog
