Reviewed: The Help
by Eleri Anona Watson
In the race-torn suburbs of 1960s Jackson, Mississippi, budding writer Eugenia ‘Skeeter’ Phelan (Emma Stone) embarks on a secret writing project. By documenting the experiences of black housekeepers in the South, she asks the perennially unanswered question of her time: “What is it like to be you?”
Director Tate Tyler’s second feature film, civil rights drama The Help was a box-office success in the US, topping charts for three straight weekends. A smash-hit it may be, but whilst The Help is perhaps a reasonably accurate representation of the period in question, it lacked originality in the much-trodden path of civil rights movies.
Much of the film’s commercial success is due to the furore surrounding rising-star, Emma Stone. The Easy A actress has in recent months graced the cover of Vanity Fair and become the unwitting subject of a highly unusual video blog by none other than comedian Jim Carrey. Brush past the hype, however, and the young actress falls flat in the film. Significantly, this is her first venture outside the comfort of the teenage rom-com genre.
A persistently dull portrayal, she succeeds in delivering almost every line without an ounce of the sentiment and intimacy that is demanded of such an intrusive character. The only explanation is that she is attempting to create the Oscar-winning feeling of ‘atmosphere’ from monotony of tone and rhythm. Stone’s performance is overshadowed by that of her extraordinary co-star and Oscar hopeful, Viola Davis whose role as maid Aibeleen Clark provides the closeness and truth of feeling where Stone fails.
The failure of the picture is ultimately due to the whitewash directing of the inexperienced Tate Taylor, who attempts to craft a balance between the picturesque and silent with the fast-paced. All to no avail. In scenes between Davis and Stone where silence and beauty of stillness is almost achieved, the film is cut. This destroys any possible sense of reverence, rendering the picture a series of amusing scenettes.
Even more frustrating than the constant chopping and changing of scenes is the lack of soundtrack in the film. There are one or two flourishes of brilliance, as tracks such as Chuck Berry’s ‘Twist and Shout’ are gamefully contrasted with the pervading tension between Skeeter and the ‘evil queen’ figure of Hilly Hoolbrook (Bryce Dallas Howard), yet I found myself begging for more of such contrast and for more directorial humour.
Therefore, whilst the film may be an amusing take on the Civil Rights Movement, it holds no reverberating message that echoes through the ages. Instead, The Help offers us a patronising glimpse of how far America has come, yet it does not look ahead to how far it still has to go. I could not help but feel that ‘The Help’ was a missed opportunity not only for Tate Taylor but also for actress Emma Stone.

