Reviewed: The Five-Year Engagement

Jason Segel and Emily Blunt in The Five-Year Engagement

by Phil M. Soc – 4/5

It’s hard to escape Judd Apatow. For the past decade the comedian-cum-writer-cum-director has had a monopoly on adult comedy. Any American comedy of note has had him credited in some role and, despite some major flops (such as his most recent directorial turn, Funny People), they still rake in the money. The formula hasn’t changed in years and with the dire Hangover II and forcibly hyped Bridesmaids last year, it’s getting boring. The cameo’s are too samey – Jane Lynch as a bitchy boss, Jonah Hill as the goofy best friend, Christopher Mintz-Plasse as a McLovin-type – and the gross out gags are overly forced. His films now elicit sighs, rather than the previous belly laughs.

And so it comes as a refreshing surprise that the latest addition to Apatow’s universe (here he acts as producer), The Five-Year Engagement, is such a sharp departure from the predictable fare we’ve had for the past few years; it may be a comedy, but it is played with real heart. What sets this film apart from the rest is, thanks to the title, knowing from the off that it won’t be an easy journey for the likable couple, giving all of the events a downbeat undertone.

The two leads are one of the most realistic couples you’ll see in recent comedy. Played perfectly by Jason Segel and Emily Blunt, they have relentless banter, longing looks and truly passionate moments. At not one point does their relationship feel forced; these are people you’re happy to spend five years with. It is also writer Segel in particular shines. He has shown he can competently play part of a relationship after seven years in How I Met Your Mother and here gets expands upon that, having the opportunity to play something a bit more tumultuous than the relatively smooth sailing he’s had as Marshall Eriksen.

The supporting characters are equally strong, for the most part being played by unknowns. There certainly are parts here that could have been taken up by the famous faces you’d expect, but director Nicholas Stoller instead chooses to go with realistic portrayals of what could easily have been caricatures. This is incredibly important for the film; it runs about twenty minutes too long, but the colourful cast of characters stop that from ever becoming a problem.

The only other major star of note beyond the main couple is Rhys Evans, who, after the CGI heavy The Amazing Spider-Man, plays a more subtle, but still heavily reptilian characters in the form of a slimy psychology professor. His presence alone shows the aims of the film are much beyond what you’d expect from the ‘From the producers of Bridesmaids’ tag on the poster. As much stock is put in the drama as with the (numerous) jokes.

The film is ultimately another victory for the writing duo if Segel and Stoller. From Forgetting Sarah Marshall onwards they’ve proven themselves as successful alternatives to the standard gaggle of on-screen comedians and The Five-Year Engagement only works to further their supremacy. The jokes come thick and fast, with the script pulling off the large set pieces as well as witty one-liners. Due to the long time frame of the story, there’s ample opportunity to use lengthy juxtaposition and gives sub-plots time to develop organically.

The Five-Year Engagement is a surprisingly fresh movie that manages to successfully tread the fine line between drama and comedy. After equal success with the more jovial The Muppets earlier the year, the film cements Segel and Stoller’s position as some of the finest purveyors of emotional comedies around.

The Five-Year Engagement is on at The Bede Film Soc for one night only on Wednesday 24th October. Entry is £3 for non-members, £1 for members. Box office opens at 7:15pm for an 8pm start.

Photographs: Universal Pictures