Reviewed: ‘The Crucible’

By Cressida Peever

Hild Bede Theatre’s production of ‘The Crucible’ is true to the script in the sense that the audience’s enjoyment rests mainly on it. The production focuses heavily on the symbolism within the play, rather than re-interpreting Miller’s masterpiece or referencing its place in history in terms of McCarthyism.

Despite the liberty permitted to contemporary directors in comparison to the past, the direction ignores the context of the play’s birth from the Red Scare in America, giving none of Miller’s subtext to an audience with no prior knowledge of these events.

Perhaps the most daring of all the directorial decisions was to portray John Proctor – traditionally a character regretful of his past sins – as a flirt.

The direction emphasizes the good and evil within the piece, using sharp changes between steel (good) and straw (evil) lighting to demonstrate a change in tone and the presence of the church. The dramatic lighting changes are effective and help to exaggerate the sense of unease created in the first scene; as the audience enters the ‘children’ are positioned around the outskirts of the room. The notorious ritual scene that opens the play takes place amongst the audience, meaning that throughout the rest of the piece they are not only judges of the characters, but judged themselves as part of the ritual.

Unfortunately, the main weakness of the piece is the characterization of the majority of characters. Although Miller presents certain aspects of the characters as stereotypes, they are by no means flat characters, as some of the acting suggested.

Particularly the elderly characters needed further movement characterization than just placing a hand on their hunched back. Many of the actors struggled to find a middle ground between shouting and softness.

Additionally to this, their emotions could not be tracked in a logical way; there were often moments when emotions jumped between opposing feelings with no build up or decline, and without realistic responses to the other characters’ delivery.

Having said this, Elizabeth Proctor (played by Sophia Harrop) and Rebecca Nurse (Beatrice Vincent) brought wonderful depth and feeling to their lines, in addition to performing each word through the entire body.

The set was key to the atmosphere of the piece. At first a canvas covered in crosses restricts the space onstage. This gives the action a sense of claustrophobia and presents an uncomfortable scene for the audience, which is appropriate for the piece.

As the play progresses the space widens through scene changes; in the closing moments of the play, Elizabeth Proctor is smothered by the vast space around her as a symbol of her loneliness.

The use of a drum, song, and pre-recorded and offstage speech add to the carefully crafted soundscape of the production.

There is also an active exploration of the space within the entire auditorium, as well as different levels onstage. This spatial awareness could be fine-tuned, as there are moments when the characters manage to line themselves up horizontally onstage instead of making bold decisions as regards their positioning.

For an audience unacquainted with Miller, this is not the best introduction. The piece is long, and drags in places due to its lethargic reaction times. However, fans of ‘The Crucible’ will appreciate the director’s attention to symbolism and loyalty to the script. The production may not be revolutionary, but it has many redeeming features and some rising stars amongst the cast.

Photographs: Nicoletta Asciuto