Reviewed: Black Mirror

by Jonathan Peters
Charlie Brooker’s Black Mirror burst onto our screens last year. A dark dystopian satire that attempted to act as a Twilight Zone for the 21st Century, playing on our fears about the omnipresence of technology in modern life. Whilst the first series’ premiere was a tense thriller that featured the Prime Minister engaging in a carnal act with a pig, here we were treated to a more understated domestic drama, although it was no less enthralling or thought provoking.
‘Be Right Back’ centres around Martha, whose partner Ash dies in an unspecified accident. After a period of mourning she is signed up for a service that allows her to instant message a simulation of Ash that trawls through previous Facebook conversations before replying with his most realistic response. The technology evolves in each segment of the programme – soon she is able to listen to his voice on the phone, and finally his personality is reanimated inside a mail-order foetus.
This premise is used to take an interesting look at the difference between virtual relationships and real-life ones – Martha finds solace in being able to talk to Ash’s reconstructed personality on a computer, but when his online self is manifested in seemingly human form she becomes increasingly dissatisfied with their relationship. Their conversations lack the emotional intensity that she craves, and the superficiality of the ‘Facebook personality’ is laid bare when he behaves odd and distant in his human shell. Brooker also examines the way we present ourselves online – the new Ash is a perfect, airbrushed version of the real thing, but someone who represents a mere walking profile page and therefore comes across as utterly inhuman.
The technology used in the episode is futuristic but seems realistic. Brooker prophesises the dangers of disrupting the natural grieving process – Martha receives temporary comfort from Ash’s voice, but soon requires a flesh version of him to maintain the illusion that he is still there with her. Charlie Brooker has done a great job of not just crafting some pertinent satire but also layered and sympathetic characters. Hayley Atwell is excellent as Martha, delivering a tragic, realistic portrayal of a woman struggling to cope with loss. We maintain our distance from her, but simultaneously feel her pain and loneliness as the camera follows her around her empty house.
There are some problems with the episode that lose it a star. We only witness Ash alive for the first fleeting minutes of the episode, and it would have been nice to see his character developed a little more before his sudden death. After this, the pacing almost grinds to a halt, and although the issues the episode raises are intriguing, it takes a while to get to the point, and at times the drama sags.
Overall however this is a solid start to the new series of what is considered one of the best science fiction shows on TV.
Black Mirror is available on 4OD now.
