Review: ‘We’ll Have Nun of It’

By Francesca Chaplin

The first piece of HBT’s new work is an original song cycle written by finalist Finola Southgate. Set in a convent school in 1967, the work gives an insight into the lives and emotions of four female characters and deals sensitively with themes of same-sex relationships, racism, and sexual abuse. ‘We’ll Have Nun of It’ features outstandingly talented actresses, slick lighting, innovative direction, a compelling script, and songs that are piercing, potent and will stay in your head long after the show is over. In short, the play is a triumph. It justly received a unanimous standing ovation at the end of its first performance.

It is a testament to just how gripping this show is that it is difficult to select just a few favourite moments. One of the standout numbers is certainly Stella’s (Izzy Mackie) song about her native country, Ireland. As Mackie performs it her eyes shine with an earnestness that immediately endears her to the audience and enables her to create a convincing character. Another highlight is when Mary (Bella Elwes) and Eliza (Olivia Spillane) sing of their burgeoning feelings for one another (‘I hear the rustling…’). Additionally, the scene in which Stella and Bernie (Rose Galbraith) sing to one another in Gaelic is a delight to watch: the actresses’ faces are alight with joy as they hear each other speak the Irish language and savour the memory of home.

All the different production team areas come together perfectly to create a piece that is truly special. Finola Southgate proves herself to be an exceptional writer and composer. The inclusion of mini-monologues before the schoolgirls have solos creates an immediate impression of their character and emotional state, such as when Bernie speaks of not receiving letters from home before singing of the loneliness that has made her a ghost. All of Southgate’s songs are beautiful with eloquent lyrics; they are performed impeccably by both the actresses and the band under the musical direction of the talented Honor Halford-Macleod. The fact that some sections of songs are accompanied while others are a cappella means that the numbers are always dynamic and engaging. The use of ring composition is particularly effective, with the song ‘Answers’ being repeated at the end and the characters having a much more certain mindset. Director Rosie Dart must be commended because the staging is consistently captivating: a bench is used in a great variety of ways and the transitions are seamless.

The actresses are perfectly cast and excel not only as a quartet but also individually. Each is expressive, has exemplary diction, and switches between singing and playing an instrument (or does the two simultaneously) with apparent ease. Bella Elwes (Mary) convincingly portrays her character’s inner struggle with her sexuality and confusion about God, confessing that ‘There are some things I can’t confide in him’, while Olivia Spillane captures Eliza’s defiance and frustration at the limitations of her situation, pulling her hair out of its restraining band and wryly asserting that ‘The world gets liberated, while I’m here sexually frustrated.’ Rose Galbraith delivers an emotive performance as Bernie who, upon receiving a letter asking her to pay a visit, confesses to Eliza that these invitations entail sexual abuse, hauntingly stating that this has become part of her routine and that she cannot escape it: ‘There’s a time in your life you feel so low you could drop it all.’ Izzy Mackie (Stella) never fails to hold the audience’s attention, whether speaking of racial discrimination (‘No dogs, no blacks, no Irish’) or her immediate family, which, with thirteen siblings, is so great that it forms a ‘small nation.’

At the show’s end, the four actresses invoke God – ‘Lord I call thee, / Answer me freely’. Their singing moves into a gospel-like style – with Rose Galbraith delivering some impressively high notes – and they begin dancing. As they do so, they shoot genuine grins at one another and their smiles are infectious. This is one of the aspects of the play that makes it such a joy to watch: the sense of tangible comradery between the four leading actresses.

End the academic year on a high with a trip to see HBT’s ‘We’ll Have Nun of It’ – the show is exceptional and you will not regret it.

By Bethany Townsend

Hild Bede Theatre Company’s ‘We’ll Have Nun of It’ is bold, brilliant and breath-taking. An original song cycle written by Durham’s own Finola Southgate, their work is timeless and present simultaneously. The cycle is beautifully written, exploring touching stories of the displacement, abandonment and identity of four young girls living in an Irish convent school in 1967.

The performance is artful, succeeding in illustrating “the confusing nature of adolescence” with sensitivity and poignancy. With the knowledge that the writing is inspired by the experiences of some of the production team’s own relatives, the tenderness and tact depicted to the audience is all the more moving. The cast perform with delicacy and strength alike, with one’s ability to convey language a central theme. For example, Rose Galbraith’s performance of Bernie, at one moment surrounded by the unanswered letters she has written to her father, was personally moving. Equally as beautiful, the Gaelic song interwoven within the performance illustrates to the audience not only how difficult it is to articulate such traumatic experiences, but the sense of sisterhood that defies linguistic restriction
in Galbraith and Izzy Mackie’s song.

Intrinsically relevant to our own society, the celebration of queer identity was especially stirring in Olivia Spillane’s solo and Bella Elwes’s performance. Playing Eliza and Mary respectively, the actors perform with vigorous integrity in the story they share. The cast are visibly passionate about the song cycle they are performing – they illustrate to the audience a reflective maturity in their manner throughout.

The theatrical space is immersive. In St Hild and St Bede’s Caedmon Hall, it is difficult to not feel as if you are in an Irish convent school alongside the girls. The music throughout the performance is in particular need of praise – not only were the band excellent, but the cast themselves play with
vivacity too.

Southgate succeeds in creating a beautiful masterpiece – personally, I feel with further development this performance would be fitting in a professional, theatrical space. The production succeeds in meeting Southgate’s aims of “creating a space in which voices can be heard without fear, shame or rejection”, a beautiful, touching experience to be part of.