Review: ‘Vigil’

By Lydia Bennett

BBC One’s newest Sunday-night drama Vigil is the latest show everyone’s talking about, and if you’ve been watching, it’s not hard to see why. The creators of Line of Duty have been at it again, gripping the nation with a deliciously mysterious police drama, but this time it’s a bit different. The action takes place below sea level. This series takes us at least 400 metres below the surface, aboard the submarine HMS Vigil, as we step into the shoes of a solo policewoman on a mission to solve a murder mystery. It’s not all underwater fun, however, as there’s plenty of drama happening ashore too. 

This series has everything: murder, deception, Russian spies, a hint of romance, corruption, divisive opinions on the current state of the UK’s defensive strategy, you name it. Vigil is truly impressive addition to the BBC’s arsenal of top-quality drama, and the finale this week will no doubt impress us all again. 

For those of you not in the loop, Vigil follows Scottish Police Service DCI Amy Silva, who is sent to HMS Vigil, a nuclear-powered ballistic missile submarine, to investigate a mysterious death on board. This, alongside the mysterious disappearance of a Scottish fishing trawler and an incident in Florida, kept under wraps by the government, make Silva’s inquiries even more interesting. Her investigations, and those of her colleagues on land, bring the police into conflict with the Royal Navy and MI5, the British Security Service whilst also bringing up major questions over the controversial British Nuclear Programme. 

It is a mark of writing genius to be able to create a gripping and interesting series from a highly secretive, contained context such as a Royal Navy submarine.

Tom Edge is the mastermind behind Vigil’s TV magic, and magic it truly is. Edge’s ability to keep 10.2 million of us (making Vigil the BBC’s most-watched new drama of the year) returning to our TV screens every week is certainly notable. It is a mark of writing genius to be able to create a gripping and interesting series from a highly secretive, contained context such as a Royal Navy submarine – it’s not conventional but the intrigue surrounding the setting used in Vigil makes it so much more inviting. 

Suranne Jones doesn’t fail to impress in her main role.

On the topic of undeniable talent, Suranne Jones doesn’t fail to impress in her main role throughout Vigil – she steals the show (much like she does in every role she plays) as Detective Chief Inspector Amy Silva. Silva is complex, dramatic yet completely believable, all the more important as viewers experience the transition from life ashore to life on a submarine through her. If Silva’s boarding of the submarine in Episode 1 didn’t convince you enough, I don’t know what will.  

My one critique, however, is that this role seems to be a little too much like other popular roles she’s played. Is Suranne Jones stuck in a rut of playing troubled professional women who are successful, but ultimately fighting their inner demons? It certainly seems to be the case for her most successful parts (do I need to even mention Doctor Foster or even Scott & Bailey?). 

Rose Leslie’s portrayal of DS Kirsten Longacre is certainly one of the standout performances of the series so far, arguably equalling Jones in the depth of her character and dramatic ability. Most known for her role in Game of Thrones, this is a nice change for Leslie in a major British programme. It’s refreshing to see her use her Scottish accent in a Scottish narrative. Line of Duty favourite Martin Compston takes on a much smaller role than I think anyone was expecting following his character’s death in Episode 1, but he still packs a punch in the time he’s on-screen. Again, it’s great to see him use his native accent and even better when we see glimmers of Steve Arnott poking through this new character of Craig Burke. 

‘Vigil’ is another BBC triumph

To conclude, I can sing nothing but praise for Vigil and the gripping, topical drama it’s brought us over the past five weeks. Vigil is another BBC triumph and easily manages to tick the boxes we’ve come to expect of BBC drama. The unusual setting and context delivered so effortlessly and believably throughout has added an unexpected twist to the series allowing mystery and conspiracy to thrive throughout. Although my patience has suffered greatly from the unfamiliarity of weekly released episodes, each Sunday instalment has added greatly to the overall effect of Vigil’s dramatic impact and suspense. My Sunday nights have been securely in the hands of BBC One throughout Vigil’s running time, I simply hate to think of what I’ll do after the finale. It’s a must-watch. 

Image: Zhu Hongzhi via Unsplash