Review: Tomorrowland – A World Beyond

By Jonathan Peters

Image: Disney
Image: Disney

Tomorrowland: A World Beyond is a movie that I desperately want to like, but ultimately resign myself to the fact that it’s the first ever misfire from Incredibles and Ratatouille mastermind Brad Bird. Disney’s marketing has shrouded many of the story details in mystery – ostensibly to preserve a sense of mystery and wonder for when cinemagoers walk into the screening, but I suspect also that the strategy has proved helpful in covering up the fact that Tomorrowland is a long, flashy-looking film with surprisingly little substance.

It opens promisingly enough, with grizzled protagonist Frank Walker (George Clooney) narrating his childhood experience of New York’s 1964 World’s Fair, back when ‘the future was different’. Boarding Disney’s ‘It’s a Small World’ ride, Frank is transported suddenly to another dimension, arriving at the titular utopian realm. Bird wants to capture the magic of visiting Disneyland itself for the first time in this introductory scene, and he arguably succeeds, as we witness through young Frank’s eyes the impressive CGI city, and Michael Giacchino’s memorable John Williams-esque score accompanies the sweeping visuals.

Clooney and his younger self then abruptly exit the picture for a full hour, and we switch focus to Casey (Britt Robertson), self-proclaimed optimist and anti-establishment rebel who deplores the government’s winding down of space projects, and lack of imagination in society as a whole. One day an android Athena (Raffey Cassidy) delivers a pin that, when touched, takes Casey from mundane suburbia over to Tomorrowland, and the two set out to discover its mysteries, along the way finding a reclusive and embittered Frank, as well as evading killer robots who want to stop them from ever reaching the city again.

And that’s pretty much all that is explained as far as plot is concerned for the first 4/5 of the movie. For nearly two hours we learn nothing about the purpose of Tomorrowland or how it was constructed, why Frank’s state is so changed, or the ultimate motivations of many of the protagonists and antagonists. Instead there are a handful of action sequences (the best of which is shown almost in full in the movie’s main trailer) and a lot of circuitous bickering, which, while entertaining enough, delays the film’s revelations until beyond the point that we cease to care. The pacing is so off that by the time any plot elements are tied together, most of the momentum has already drained from the story.

What is the film’s driving point, once the details are filled in? It seems to be that society has become too cynical and lost its sense of wonder. Fair enough – Christopher Nolan’s Interstellar made similar arguments – but the way in which Bird conveys his ideas is cringeworthy and heavy-handed, and at times downright confusing. We are supposed to believe, for instance, that Casey is the most optimistic person in the world, capable of singlehandedly counteracting mankind’s cynicism. During a school lesson on climate change early in the film, she asks why she is only ever presented with the problems, and never ways to fix them, to the stunned silence of her teachers (and much eye-rolling in the audience… obviously you need to know the background to the problems before you can develop the solutions, duh).

Later, after the main villain has been finally revealed, it is ambiguous as to whether humans are their own worst enemy, or whether we are all being influenced through various mind control devices, and indeed throughout the movie it feels as though Bird and co-writer Damon Lindelof were unsure if they wanted to deliver a realistic state-of-the-planet motivational lecture, or an escapist sci-fi fantasy. Tomorrowland succeeds as neither – this is a film with heady aspirations, that sadly ends up feeling like a more wishy-washy Doctor Who episode in some of its plot beats.

There are some redeeming moments, however, where (if you don’t think to hard about the ideas running through each scene) Bird displays flashes of brilliance that seemed more readily available in his previous animated and live action features. The first time that Casey journeys out at night with her pin and switches back and forth between the ‘real world’ and Tomorrowland is spectacular, and in his robot and set designs Bird employs the same striking aesthetic that marked out his Cold War-set animated classic The Iron Giant. The acting also helps to carry the movie even in its most unconvincing moments, with Robertson somehow managing to be not-that-annoying in an uphill struggle of a role, and Clooney delivering a surprisingly subtle performance that conveys his adult rage yet shows flashes of his character’s hopeful younger self.

Ultimately however, Bird promises Tomorrowland, but he delivers Epcot – it’s kind of fun, but, to be honest, there are plenty of other places you’d rather be.