Review: ‘Things I Know To Be True’

By Martha Wrench

“Is there such a thing as loving a person too much?”. This is the question that Collingwood College Woodplayers attempt to answer through the course of ‘Things I Know To Be True’, a play which navigates itself through the various and troubling relationships within one family. An ambitious play to put on, the Woodplayers present a well-polished production which despite good intentions, cannot quite reach the depth of emotion that is needed.

The set is extremely minimalist but effective, made up of a single, solitary tree at the back of the performance space and two boxes of roses. Directors, Bex Gray and Lillie Rodger, make clean and quick transitions between scenes which the cast execute with ease, making for a smooth production. Attempts are also made to use lighting and music within these transitions. However, although a deeply moving and complicated play, not enough thought has been given to it as a whole, leaving it lacking in atmosphere. Greater development of the use of music and lighting would have made for a more fluid and immersive production and would have aided the building of emotion throughout the play. The size of the performance space also does not aid the atmosphere of the production. With a very small audience, the production would have benefited from moving the seating forwards to create a smaller performance space and thus generate the feeling of claustrophobia which is a significant theme within the play. To be closer to the performers would have therefore aided the emotional impact of the production.

The performances that are given by individuals are generally well done. Jemima Abate provides her 18 year old character with a youthfulness which acts as a good contrast to the other characters, although it occasionally moves slightly too far into childish mannerisms. Will Hobbs does a pleasing job portraying Bob, the 63 year old father (quite a stretch for any student). He comes across endearingly throughout much of the production and is able to make the transitions into heavier emotional material when needed. His scene with Ben (played by Michael Gaughan) is one of the strongest in the production and carries the emotional weight well. Dylan Hicks also provides one of the most moving scenes in the play as Mark, ably portraying the pain and conflict that he feels at his family’s reaction to him coming out as a transgender woman.

Although certain elements of individuals’ performances were successful, greater development in characterisation is needed overall in order to carry the full weight of the play. More emotional depth is needed all-round with much of the performances able to give a surface level understanding of their characters and emotions but lacking the truth and real motivation behind the words. Connection between the characters could have also been further improved by developing the relationships between the characters. The different relationship which each child has with the mother is something that is particularly important and also very complex. More time could have been spent on developing these relationships so that their differing dynamics would have become more apparent to the audience. Without this development, many of the characters and their backstories felt hollow and let down the potential for great emotional impact which is present in the writing.

As a result of this lack of emotional development, the play tends to drag, becoming monotonous in its delivery. There is no clear progression of emotional tension even during the increasing disintegration of the family, leaving it to plateau. More directorial attention to the delivery of lines would have been useful in marking greater dynamic shifts with perhaps the addition of music and more interesting lighting able to create these shifts in mood and tone. Many significant lines are lost as a result of carelessness in delivery and as such, a great deal of the emotional impact is lost. The pacing remains the same throughout the production which could have been remedied by slowing some parts down and using more silences to increase the tenderness of particular moments, and by increasing the pace and thus the dynamism of other parts.

Furthermore, the physical movement which is such a key part of this play is somewhat lacking. Apart from the repeated motif of creating a chain of hands with members of the family, the physical movement is sparse and lacks reasoning. It does not appear to add anything to this production other than occasional moments of cheesiness which I am sure was not its intention. It is a shame as with greater development, physical theatre would have been a great component to this production.

Nevertheless, Collingwood College Woodplayers make an admirable attempt at portraying the complexities and intricacies of this very challenging play. Although it must be said that much of the emotional impact is reliant on the excellent writing itself, this is not a production that is completely void of talent. Many of the actors give touching performances and the production is extremely well polished. This is a production with great potential which with a little more development could be excellent.

Image Credit: Collingwood College Woodplayers