Review: ‘The Great European Disaster Movie’

italian soc

By Kit Evans

On Monday 25th January, that ultimately was the question posed to the audience of Durham University Italian Society’s screening of ‘The Great European Disaster Movie’. The director of the movie, Annalisa Piras, and the executive producer, Bill Emmott then answered questions from the audience with Durham’s own Dr. Christian Schweiger, an expert on all things Europe, from the School of Government and International Affairs, chairing the discussion.

The ‘documentary’, which was first aired on BBC Four last March, set sometime in the near future begins on board a plane, somewhere over Europe. Whilst we are not certain what state the European Union is in, the oftentimes crude metaphor of the plane in turbulence hints to us that it is clearly not a good one.

When the movie was conceived in 2015, Piras and Emmott saw a number of worrying trajectories in which the EU was heading. In response to this realization, Piras wanted to make a ‘1984’ for the modern age, something that would “look to the future to offer a warning to the present”. Piras admitted, however, with lamentation, since the conception of ‘The Great European Disaster Movie’, the worst of these trajectories has been realised, with Emmott and Piras emphasising the EU’s reaction to the refugee crisis.

A brief video montage of Europe’s history started with the destruction brought on by World War II and moved through to the problems in the Ukraine in 2013, and today’s refugee crisis. We then leaped into the realm of journalistic divination with the prediction that a ‘Brexit’ would cause a domino effect of other countries leaving the EU, eventually leading to its collapse in 2022.

Whilst the Angus Deayton entertains us playing an archaeologist, who somehow manages to chart the history of the EU with some very questionable objects, it is in the five case studies that the real drama unfolds.

Catalonians reflect on how Spain is suffering hugely from the post-2008 house crisis, and yet the EU seems to be doing nothing. Sweden tells us that immigration is a universal good, particularly in an ageing society, but that anger at politicians is being misdirected at foreigners. The German case study was more sombre with the events of 70 years ago still holding huge impact over today’s actions. The UK, on the other hand, was used to provide some light comedy it seemed, with a segment lasting a few minutes regarding how a Margate hotelier had been forced, by the EU, to change the butter used in their ‘butter curls’.

A look at the final country, Croatia, was perhaps the most effective in advocating that something be done to retain the institution of economic alliance and subsequent peace-keeping that is the EU. Whilst the EU may have ostensibly started as an economic union, its pure motive was to ensure an interdependent relationship between France and Germany after World War II. When Croatia joined the EU in 2013, it was only two decades after the disintegration of Yugoslavia, and even less time since the Yugoslav Wars. The newest members of the EU have greater faith in the European project, because dictatorship, war, and genocide still exist in recent memory. These newcomers have a hunger for the security and opportunity that the EU provides Europe.

After seeing the movie, when asked whether people were optimistic about the EU’s future, the audience’s response was heavily to the contrary. Then when asked how much should be done to save the EU, the resounding response, from those who support the EU that is, was that everything from everyone should be used to save it.

But what can practically be done, one may ask, and rightly so. ‘The Great European Disaster Movie’ was very good at pointing out the problems with the EU, but its overall power was negated at times by its lack of solutions. Having said this, it made a strong case for e-democracy, a movement being tested in Switzerland. It is thought electronic voting may make the relationship between the EU and citizen stronger, according to Scytl, a Spanish e-democracy think-tank.

This may not be the most effective delivery of the European story, but it is a story that needs to be told nonetheless. Piras and Emmott’s desperation for something to change is clear, particularly with the ‘Wake Up Europe’ campaign. The EU is a highly imperfect work-in-progress but its intentions and its potential is good, especially since its existence has been predicated on exceeding people’s expectations.

Photograph: Durham University Italian Society via Facebook